PMW Special Report on USAID presented to members of US Congress (PMW-PALESTINIAN MEDIA WATCH) By Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook Special Report - June 24, 2005)
Source: http://www.pmw.org.il
PMW} PALESTINIAN MEDIA WATCH
PMW} PALESTINIAN MEDIA WATCH Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
PMW report presented to members of United States Congress:
Alleges violations of US law in US funding of the PA
Congresswoman Nita Lowey:
"I am very disturbed by the findings of this report."
At a briefing to the Mid East Sub-Committee of the International
Relations
Committee in the US House of Representatives on Friday, Palestinian
Media
Watch (PMW) Director Itamar Marcus released the organization´s new
report
that documents the fact that the US Agency for International
Development
(USAID) is distributing millions of dollars to institutions and
frameworks
in the Palestinian Authority that should be ineligible for funding by
US
law.
Congresswoman Nita Lowey, of New York, told the NY Sun that USAID
must
respond to Palestinian Media Watch´s allegations. "I am very
disturbed by
the findings of this report, particularly the widespread nature of
the
alleged violations," she said. "I will ask USAID to provide Congress
with a
detailed response to these findings immediately. This report cannot
go
unanswered by the leadership of USAID."
US law prohibits the funding of any governmental structure,
institution,
organization or company that sponsors or promotes terrorism. US money
likewise must not go to honoring terrorists. Yet the 22-page PMW
report
documents numerous problematic examples in US funding procedures. For
example:
Palestinian universities continue to host branches of Hamas and
Islamic
Jihad, and are should be ineligible for US aid. Yet USAID is
distributing
millions of dollars to these universities.
PA municipalities have changed street names to the names of
terrorists and
should therefore be ineligible for US aid, yet municipalities
continue to
receive money - even for municipal road works.
Last year PMW released a report to Congress entitled "Four Loopholes
in US
Anti-Terror Funding Laws" which recommended six amendments to US law.
In the
2005 Foreign Operations Bill, Congress adopted all six PMW
recommendations.
This PMW report documents what seem to be violations of these new US
government restrictions.
Palestinian Media Watch
Special Report - June 24, 2005
US Funding in the Palestinian Authority under Mahmoud Abbas
Violates 2005 Foreign Operations Bill:
Recipients support, legitimize and honor terrorists
By Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook
Executive Summary
US law prohibits the funding of any governmental structure,
institution,
organization or company that sponsors or promotes terrorism.
Governmental and non-governmental organizations in the Palestinian
Authority
(PA) continue to receive hundreds of millions of dollars from the US
Agency
for International Development (USAID), some of which is going
directly to
frameworks that sponsor branches of the Hamas and Islamic Jihad
terrorist
organizations, and to others that glorify terrorists and terrorism,
delegitimize Israel´s existence and promote hatred of the American
people,
government and values.
This report documents these violations of US law.
Table of Contents
Introduction
1.A. PA Legitimizing Terror and Honoring Terrorists
1.B. Frameworks Supporting and Honoring Terrorists
2. US Funding
3. Palestinian Authority Promotion of Hatred of America
Appendix
Introduction
Supporting, Legitimizing and Honoring Terrorists
The presentation of terrorism as legitimate "resistance," together
with the
honoring of terrorists, both past and present, was a cornerstone of
Palestinian Authority (PA) ideology and society during the Arafat
era. It
continues today under the administration of Mahmoud Abbas.
All Palestinian universities continue to host branches of Hamas and
Islamic
Jihad, yet receive millions of dollars in US aid. Numerous suicide
terrorists have come from these universities.
Sport remains a prime means of glorifying terror and honoring
terrorists.
Sporting events, teams and arenas for adults and children continue to
be
named in honor of terrorists.
Street names have been changed to names of terrorists by
municipalities,
including those where USAID funding has sponsored municipal road
works and
continues to fund other infrastructure activities.
International Women´s Day, in March 2005, saw repeated PA promotion
of the
ideal Palestinian woman as one who joyously sends her sons to die as
Shahids - Martyrs who die for Allah.
Israel´s existence continues to be presented as illegitimate. In
February
2005, a salaried PA cleric on PA TV promised Israel´s destruction
through
conquest, after a diplomatic process that would return Israel to the
1967
borders. In May the same cleric preached that Islam would conquer the
US and
other Christian countries while exterminating all Jews. Musical
broadcasts
involving children likewise continue to preach delegitimization of
Israel
and violence for children: "Though [conquering all of Jerusalem] is
my
dream, I can achieve it with my blood," says a child in a special
program
broadcast more than 15 times this past year, including twice in May
2005.
Current US funding of the PA is in violation of US Law
Funding of the Palestinian Authority, its municipalities and its
universities is in violation of the 2005 Foreign Operations Bill
(SEC.
559.b-c) which prohibits money for any "individual, private or
government
entity, or educational institution that the Secretary knows or has
reason to
believe advocates, plans, sponsors, engages in, or has engaged in,
terrorist
activity..." In such a case, the Secretary "shall terminate
assistance to
any individual, entity, or educational institution which he has
determined
to be involved in or advocating terrorist activity. (c)... None of
the funds
... may be made available for the purpose of recognizing or otherwise
honoring individuals who commit, or have committed, acts of
terrorism." (See
Appendix for full text)
Congress enacted these amendments after a 2004 Palestinian Media
Watch
report documented the widespread use of sport and other social and
educational infrastructures to honor terrorists and thereby promote
terrorism. The objective of Congress was to prevent US money from
going to
any of these frameworks, so that US foreign aid would promote and
support a
healthy and non-violent PA society.
Today, US money continues to be used to directly and indirectly
promote and
honor terrorists. Under the leadership of Abbas, the PA continues to
sustain
many of the infrastructures that promote terror, and to fund PA
ministries
that actively support terror and honor terrorists.
For example, the PA sponsors sporting events that honor terrorists. A
February 2005 marathon, sponsored by Chairman Mahmoud Abbas himself,
was won
by a 14-year-old from the "Shahid Salah Khalaf Center." [Al-Hayat
Al-Jadida, February 7, 2005] A Shahid is a ´Martyr of Allah´ and,
according
to Palestinian Authority terminology, includes suicide bombers.
Salah Khalaf - or "Abu Iyad" - was the head of the "Black September"
terrorist organization responsible for killing 11 Israeli athletes at
the
1972 Munich Olympics and two American diplomats in Sudan a year
later.
Supporting an infrastructure that honors terrorists is a violation of
US
law.
In May 2005, the PA Table Tennis Union sponsored a table tennis
tournament
honoring two heads of the Hamas terror organization, responsible for
hundreds of deaths of Israelis and Americans.
US money continues to promote and honor terrorists directly and
indirectly,
through the funding of PA municipalities that use their budgets to
honor
terrorists. For example, Gaza has renamed 300 streets after Shahids,
including a street named for former Hamas leader Ahmad Yassin. The
city of
Khan Yunis spent significant money to change "300 metal street
signs ...
most of them to names of Shahids..." and named "the most important
street in
the city after the Shahid Ahmad Yassin." (References below).
1.A. Legitimizing Terror and Honoring Terrorists
1.A.1. Reaction to the suicide terror attack of February 25, 2005:
Palestinian terror continues to be presented as legitimate. Although
PA
leaders condemn terrorist attacks in the Western media and diplomatic
circles, the suicide terrorist who killed five Israelis at a Tel Aviv
nightclub in February 2005 - as well as every terrorist killed by
Israeli
security forces and every suicide bomber up until publication of this
report - are labeled in the PA Arabic-language newspapers as Shahids -
Martyrs for Allah. By granting Shahid status to murderers, the PA
media,
including the PA-owned Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, are portraying even
suicide
terrorism as a positive religious act - the supreme Islamic
achievement.
Rather than condemned for being an act of murder, the February
suicide
terror attack was criticized as "poorly timed," "unnecessary" and
damaging
to the PA. The relationship between terror and the political process
is
defined as "sowing and harvesting."
1.A.1.1. The suicide terrorist was honored in all the PA dailies
"The executor of the Tel Aviv operation, the Shahid Abdullah Badran."
[Front-page caption in official PA daily Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, February
27,
2005 under large color photo of the terrorist.]
"The family of the Shahid..." [Al-Ayyam, February 27, 2005]
"The family of the Shahid Abdullah..."
".the Shahid´s two brothers."
".mourning tent in memory of the Shahid."[Al-Quds, February 27, 2005]
1.A.1.2. The timing and political damage was condemned
Hassan Asfour, Member of the Palestinian Legislative Council:
"This is the first action that no one is happy about. Everyone felt
that the
timing was not [right] and there was absolutely no need for it... It
is not
because the resistance [the PA term for terror] against the
occupation is a
mistake, but because the nature, location and timing of the action
are a
mistake."
[PA TV, February 28, 2005]
"Presidential advisor Nabil Abu Rudaynah [said the PA] condemns this
operation, especially coming after the Hudna [temporary cease fire]
and the
calming, which were achieved with the [terrorist] factions... The
Authority
opposes any action that targets civilians. This is a part of the
Hudna,
which was declared in Sharm Al-Sheik. We oppose any violation of this
Hudna.
He also clarified that this sort of action harms the supreme national
interests of the Palestinian people."[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, February
26, 2005]
1.A.2. Terror bad because of the "balance of power"
Mahmoud Abbas, Chairman of the Palestinian Authority:
"We announced a ceasefire. In its essence, the Intifada was an
intifada of
peace and popular. When it moved to shooting it caused us great
damage and
grievous tragedies. The balance of power is not equal and therefore
we have
no choice but to stop it." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, February 17, 2005]
1.A.3. ´Warrior Rest´: Period of calm is to build up power for the
future
"They [Hamas, Islamic Jihad, etc.] responded to the language of
reason, and
accepted the call for a "period of calm" by the President Mahmoud
Abbas...
They understood the need of time for the warrior rest. Our brothers,
a
warrior needs a rest... when the Prophet, rest his soul, fought his
enemies,
he did not invade twice in one year. The first year he invaded Bader,
the
second he invaded Hajra... Our interest requires that we reserve our
blood
and weapons so that we can cope with what is greater."
[Senior PA salaried religious leader, Ibrahim Mudayris, PA TV,
February 11,
2005]
1.A.4. Samir Mash´harwi, Fatah Central Committee: "Rest of the
fighters"
"Where do we and the factions (Hamas, etc) disagree?
"Regarding how to reach [the Palestinian goal]. Will we reach it
through
resistance [that is, terrorism] and resistance alone, or through
resistance
with all forms of Palestinian struggle: diplomatic activity, popular
intifada, armed resistance, achieving international support in the
international arena?
"We in Fatah say we have to include it all - and to choose the
appropriate
time for the rifle and the appropriate time for negotiations... We
see this
period of negotiations as the ´rest of the fighters.´" [PA TV,
January 10,
2005]
1.A.5. The High Commissioner of National Education:
"We expect to utilize all that we have sowed and sacrificed [and
expect]
that the political leadership, headed by our brother Abu Mazen, will
succeed
to begin the harvesting process..." [PA TV February 11, 2005]
1.B. Frameworks Supporting Terror and Honoring Terrorists
1.B.1. PA Ministry of Education and Higher Learning - Active
university-sponsored terrorist branches on campus
The PA Ministry of Education and Higher Learning actively funds
terrorism,
as every university in the Palestinian Authority has a branch of
Hamas and
Islamic Jihad - both of which are on the US list of terror
organizations.
The Hamas and Islamic Jihad student branches at the PA universities
have
historically been a breeding ground for terrorists, as campus
structures are
used to promote murder and terror, and to recruit and plan terrorist
activities. Numerous terrorists, including suicide terrorists, have
been
recruited from these university terror organizations. The 21-year-old
woman
terrorist caught on June 20, 2005 with 15 pounds of explosives hidden
in her
underwear - on her way to a planned terror attack at an Israeli
hospital -
was a student at Al-Quds Open University.
1.B.1.1. The following are examples from the PA media, documenting
the
existence of terrorist organizations in PA universities and various
activities:
1.B.1.1.1. Al-Najah University
"Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [´The Islamic Bloc,´ Hamas´ student
organization] in
the Faculty of Technology of Al-Najah National University yesterday
organized the ´Bridge of the Shahids´ exhibition... The exhibition
was
opened by the Faculty Dean, Dr. Samir Mayalah, and some lecturers and
a
representative of the Islamic Bloc [i.e. Hamas]. The exhibition is a
part of
the activities marking Shahids´ Week." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 29,
2005]
"Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [of Hamas] of Al-Najah National University
organized
a mass assembly in which a member of the political bureau of the
Islamic
Resistance Movement, "Hamas," in Nablus, Mahmoud Ghazal ...
said: ´The
movement shall not forget the great Shahids and the great leaders of
the
Palestinian nation, and foremost the Shahid, the Imam Ahmad Yassin,
the
Shahid Dr. Abd Al-Aziz Al-Rantisi..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, April 10,
2005]
A month after 15 Israelis were murdered in the August 2001 Sbarro
Pizzeria
bomb, Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [Hamas] at the Al-Najah University
created a
horrific celebration, by building a mock Sbarro pizza shop and
decorating
the walls and tables with images of pizza and body parts.
In spite of this open sponsorship of Hamas on campus and the active
Hamas
branch, Al-Najah University is a recipient of USAID funding. See
Section 2.1
below.
1.B.1.1.2. Al-Quds Open University
"In Hebron an assembly was organized yesterday, marking the first
anniversary of the assassination of the Islamic Resistance Movement -
"Hamas" - founder, Sheik Ahmed Yassin, and of its leader, Dr. Abd Al-
Aziz
Al-Rantisi. The assembly was organized by Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [of
Hamas]
in the Al-Quds Open University... Taysir Abu Sakur, on behalf of the
university´s administration ... recalled the Shahids of our
people..."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, 22/03/05]
"During a symposium organized by the Al-Quds Open University in
northern
Gaza, ... a member of the political bureau of the Popular Front [for
the
Liberation of Palestine] said, ´Our duty is to turn the election
procedure
into a campaign against the Occupation and the American plan... The
United
States is interested in turning the elections to its favor, and
interested
in reorganizing our people and institutions so it would fit the
United
States plans´." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, April 20, 2005. It should be
noted that
in the language of the terrorist groups and the Palestinian
Authority, the
term ´the Occupation´ refers to all of Israel, and not just the
territories.]
In spite of this active terrorist branch, Al-Quds Open University is
a
recipient of USAID funding. See Section 2.1 below.
1.B.1.1.3. Al-Azhar University
"The council of students´ union at Al-Azhar University and the Fatah
Al-Shabiba Organization held a students´ mass meeting yesterday,
under the
title ´Oath and Loyalty to the Shahids,´ marking the anniversary of
the
death as a Shahid of the Prince of the Shahids, Khalil Al-Wazir "Abu
Jihad..." The Gaza Al-Azhar University President, Dr. Hani Najem,
emphasized
in his speech that our people will continue to be loyal to the blood
of our
Shahids...
"Head of the Fatah Al-Shabiba Organization, Abd Al-Hakim Awd,
described
Al-Azhar University as the University of the Shahids." [Al-Hayat Al-
Jadida,
April 20, 2005]
In spite of this active terrorist branch, Al-Azhar University is a
recipient
of USAID funding. See Section 2.1 below.
1.B.1.1.4. Arab-American University
"Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [of Hamas] of the Arab-American University in
Jenin..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 1, 2005]
Headline: "An assembly of the parties running for elections of the
student
council at the Arab-American University..."
"These are the parties: The Islamic Loyalty Bloc, a coalition of Al-
Kutlah
Al-Islamiyah and Al-Jamaa´ Al-Islamiyah [Islamic Jihad]; the Al-Aqsa
Shahids
Bloc, representing the Al-Shabibah Student Movement [of Fatah]; the
Unity
Students Bloc [of the Democratic Front for the Liberation of
Palestine];
[and] the Shahid Abu Ali Mustafa Bloc [of the Popular Front for the
Liberation of Palestine]."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 15, 2005]
In spite of these active terrorist Hamas and Islamic Jihad branches,
the
American University is a recipient of USAID funding. See Section 2.1
below.
1.B.1.1.5. Islamic University
"Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah [of Hamas] won the elections for the male
student
council and for the female student council at the Islamic University."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 15, 2005]
"The senior [leader] in the Hamas, Sheik Isma´il Hania, spoke in
front of
thousands of students ... in the Islamic University in Gaza ...
[saying]
´the American and Zionist attempts will not succeed in dismantling
the
Resistance of its weapon. The Resistance will not desert its weapon
and will
not hand it to anyone, because it is the weapon of Jihad, resistance,
honor,
nobility and a wing to hit the [Zionist] lie and defend the people".
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 4, 2005]
In spite of this open support of terrorists on campus and the active
Hamas
branch, the Islamic University is a recipient of USAID funding. See
Section
2.1 below.
1.B.4.1.6. Bethlehem University
"The Unity Students Bloc at Bethlehem University ... [is]
commemorating the
36th anniversary of the founding of the Democratic Front for the
Liberation
of Palestine..."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 1, 2005]
In spite of this open support of terrorists on campus and the active
terrorist branch, Bethlehem University is a recipient of USAID
funding. See
Section 2.1 below.
1.B.1.1.7. Bir Zeit University
"The Minister of Negotiations Dr. Sa´eb Erekat ... said in Bir Zeit
University, ´Israel was a functional state from the beginning, and
was
established for the sake of defending Western interests... Bush has
appointed himself as being responsible for and a negotiator on behalf
of the
Palestinians, as he approved his unilateral separation plan on April
15th
last year, but no one can negotiate on our behalf."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, February 7, 2005]
In spite of this open support of terrorists on campus and the active
Hamas
branch - Bir Zeit University is a recipient of USAID funding. See
Section
2.1 below.
1.B.1.1.8. Hebron University
"...The university decided to grant scholarships named for the
journalist
Mazen Da´na." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 4, 2005. Mazen Da´na was a
TV
cameraman shot by American forces in Iraq on August 17, 2003, as his
camera
was suspected of being a grenade launcher]
In spite of this open support of terrorists on campus and the active
Hamas
branch, Hebron University is a recipient of USAID funding. See
Section 2.1
below.
1.B.1.2. Terrorists who have come directly from PA university
activity
include:
Mahmoud Shuraytakh: Chairman of Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah of Hamas and
of the
Student Council at Bir Zeit University. Planned a suicide attack on a
bus in
Tel Aviv September 19, 2002, in which six Israelis were murdered and
71
injured.
Ihab Abdul Qadir Mahmoud Abu Salim: Arab Language student and a
member of
Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah at Bir Zeit University. Carried out a suicide
attack
at Zerifin September 9, 2003, in which eight Israelis were murdered
and
about 20 injured.
Daya Muhammad Hussein Al-Tawil: Engineering student at Bir Zeit
University
and a member of Al-Kutlah Al-Islamiyah. Carried out a suicide attack
at the
French Hill junction in Jerusalem March 27, 2001, in which 29
Israelis were
injured.
Ramiz Ubaid: Student and a member of Al-Jama´a Al-Islamiyah (Islamic
Jihad)
at Bir Zeit University. Carried out a suicide attack at Dizengoff
Center in
Tel Aviv March 3, 1996, in which 13 Israelis were murdered and 118
injured.
Hamid Abu Hajlah: Engineering student and a member of Al-Kutlah Al-
Islamiyah
at Al-Najah University. Carried out a suicide attack in Netanya on
January
1, 2001, in which three Israelis were injured.
Ramiz Abu Salim: Hamas activist and a student at Al-Quds Open
University
branch in Al-Birah. Carried out a suicide attack at Cafe Hillel in
Jerusalem
September 9, 2003, in which seven Israelis were murdered and about 20
injured.
Muhammad Al-Rul: Hamas activist and a student at Al-Najah University.
Carried out a suicide attack in Jerusalem June 18, 2002, in which 19
Israelis were murdered and 42 injured.
1.B.1.3. PA Deceives USAID regarding renaming of schools
In addition, many schools are named for terrorists - celebrating them
as
role models and heroes for children. In the lead-up to the recent PA
municipal elections, the December 14, 2004 Al-Hayat Al-Jadida
published a
list of ballot box locations, which included 34 schools named for
Shahids
and/or terrorists.
One significant mention was the Dalal Al-Mughrabi High School for
Girls, in
the Shuyukh district, near Hebron. Al-Mughrabi was a woman terrorist
who
killed 36 people, including American nature photographer Gail Rubin
in 1978.
In August 2002, Palestinian Media Watch reported that USAID was
funding
renovations in this school. The State Department immediately froze
the
funding to the school, conditioning a return of the funding to having
the
school´s name changed. Larry Garber, then-USAID Mission Director in
the West
Bank and Gaza, told Reuters at the time that it was of "critical
importance"
that US funds were not associated with projects that
glorify "terrorism or
other forms of violence." The school promised USAID officials that it
had
changed the name and USAID was quick to reinstate the funding, which
had
been frozen for only 24 hours. Philip Davies, Vice-President of the
subcontracting NGO, ANERA, told The Jerusalem Post, "They changed the
name
back. So there´s no issue any more."
However, this appeared in a recent list of polling stations:
"...the Dalal Al-Mughrabi High School for Girls, in the election area
of the
Shuyukh in the Hebron district."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, December 14, 2004]
It is clear that USAID was deceived, or failed to follow up on the
issue.
Either the PA never changed the name, or waited just long enough to
receive
US money, then reverted to the name of the notorious female terrorist.
This lack of follow-up applies to other USAID-funded projects. In
June 2004,
a Palestinian Media Watch report on loopholes in US foreign aid
revealed
that some $410,000 in American aid had helped finance the Salah
Khalaf
Recreation and Sports Center near Nablus. Salah Khalaf, also known as
Abu
Iyad, was leader of the Palestinian Black September terror
organization that
was responsible for the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes at the 1972
Munich
Olympics and the killing of two US diplomats in Sudan the following
year.
Various references in honor of Salah Khalaf by the Palestinian
Authority
have been already been listed in this report.
Following the publication of the Palestinian Media Watch report,
members of
the US Congress acted immediately to tighten US foreign aid
regulations.
USAID´s Garber said the agency would demand that the name of the
stadium be
changed. "We are having a dialogue with the appropriate Palestinian
officials on the subject," Garber told The Washington Times in June
last
year. However, Palestinian Media Watch has recently contacted the
local
municipality, and was informed that the stadium is still named after
the
terrorist Salah Khalaf.
1.B.2. Naming Sporting Events and Teams for Terrorists - 2005
The following are examples of the continued use of sporting events in
2005
to honor and create role models of terrorists. These sports
infrastructures
are funded by the PA Ministry of Youth and Sport from the general PA
budget.
"The tournament ... for 17-year-old boys takes place at the Shahid
Sa´ed
Sa´el Hall. The tournament is organized by the Ministry of Youth and
Sports... [The teams:] The Shahid Salah Khalaf team, the Shahid Nabil
Qablan
team and the Shahid Atif Bsiso team." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January
25, 2005.
Salah Khalef "Abu Iyad" (1930-1991) was a founder of the Fatah
terrorist
organization and head of the "Black September" terrorist
organization.
Responsible for killing 11 Israeli Olympic and two American
diplomats. Ataf
Bsiso was Abu Iyad´s deputy. He was killed in Paris in 1992. Sa´ed
Sa´el
(1931-1982) was a senior Fatah man, Chief-of-Staff of the
Palestinian-Lebanese terrorist forces and Director of the PLO Anti-
IDF
operation center until 1982.]
"Al-Fallah Sports Center ... announced that it will hold a table-
tennis
tournament early next week ... [including the teams:] "The return"
mosque
team (Al-Auda) and the Shahid Imad Aqel team." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida,
January
27, 2005. Imed Aqel was a senior Hamas terrorist before being killed
by
Israeli forces.]
"The Shahid Khaled Abu Salmia Memorial Football Tournament, ... under
the
supervision of the Palestinian Football Association..." [Al-Hayat Al-
Jadida,
January 16, 2005. Khaled Abu Salmia was the field commander of the
Hamas´
Izz Al-Din Al-Kassam Brigades.]
"The team trained at the Shahid Salah Khalaf [Abu Iyad] Center..."
[Al-Hayat
Al-Jadida, January 25, 2005]
"The Shahid Salah Khalaf Cultural Center, in cooperation with the
Shahid
Rafik Al-Islami Hall, under the sponsorship of Amin Al-Hindi, the
commander
of the general intelligence, have organized a football tournament ...
in
memory of the anniversary of the Shahada death of the three leaders,
the
Shahid Ha´el Abd Al-Hamid, the Shahid Fakhri Al-Umri, and the Shahid
Salah
Khalaf [Abu Iyad]. The tournament took place at the Shahid Sa´ed
Sa´el
Hall..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 17, 2005. Ha´el Abd Al-
Hamid "Abu
Al-Hul" was a founder of the Fatah terror organization, Sa´ed Sa´el
was a
senior Fatah terrorist.]
"The Tulkarem Culture [Club] junior team ... won the tournament
cup... The
tournament was organized by the Al-Quds Open University. The
participating
teams: the Al-Quds Open University team, ... [and] the Shahid Fadi
Bahti
team..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 17, 2005. Fadi Bassam Mahmoud
Bahti
was an Islamic Jihad leader in Nablus. He was an explosives expert,
in
charge of a bomb-building lab and was responsible for sending suicide
terrorists to Israel.]
"The marathon, organized by the National Association of Shahids´
Families of
Palestine, under the supervision of the Palestinian Athletics
Association
and sponsored by the President of the Palestinian Authority "Abu
Mazen"
Mahmoud Abbas, has ended. It was held in honor of his victory in the
presidential elections... The three kilometer race for children under
14
years of age was won by Mahmoud Abu Kwik from the Shahid Salah Khalaf
center..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, February 7, 2005]
Ahmed Al-Kidwa, chairman of the Palestinian Olympic committee:
"When we joined the Fatah movement, we joined as potential Shahids.
Many of
our brothers died as Shahids during our struggle." He
emphasized, "The main
aim is to reach one of the two positive goals: victory or Shahada.
The
person, who arrived as a potential Shahid, may not cease before he
reaches
one of these positive goals: either Shahada and joining his brothers
who
preceded him, or achieving the full victory which we desire for our
nation."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 17, 2005]
1.B.2. Naming Streets for Terrorists
1.B.2.1. Gaza
"Gaza City Council decided to name one of the streets in city after
the
Shahid, the distinguished Sheik [and former Hamas Leader] Ahmad
Yassin, in
perpetuation and cherishing of his struggle and sacrifice. The
council
Spokesmen, Nassar Al-Suiwair ... said that since it began its term
ten years
ago, the city council has named over three hundred streets after a
large
group of Arab and Palestinian Shahids...
"The city council announced that the American Agency for Development
has
decided to grant the city council three hundred and eighty thousand
dollars,
as a part of the ´Cash Transfer´ program, in cooperation with the
Ministry
of Finance and the Ministry of Local Government, to cover some of the
cost
of repairing the damages in the water and sewage systems in the Al-
Zaitun
neighborhood." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, May 24, 2004]
1.B.2.2. Khan Yunis
"Yesterday, the city council of Khan Yunis began a campaign to name
streets
after Shahids and historical cities.
"Mayor Dr. Osama Al-Farah: "The city council will work ... to name
the most
important street in the city after [the former Hamas Leader,]
theShahid
Ahmad Yassin.
"In addition [streets will be named for]... Haifa and Acco."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, May 31, 2004]
"The mayor of Khan-Yunis, Dr. Osama Al-Farah, said yesterday that the
council crews finished the project of naming the city streets during
which
some 300 metal signs were put on many streets. Most of [the streets]
carry
the names of Shahids, commanders and Palestinian cities, which were
conquered by the Israeli Army during the period of 1948-1967.
"Al-Farah clarified that the city council initiated the project of
changing
the street names ... in light of the importance of these names in
affixing
great historical events in the hearts and minds of the people,
particularly
among the younger generation, in order to engrave the Israeli crimes,
which
led to the robbery of our cities and villages, in their memory..."
[Al-Hayat
Al-Jadida, June 28, 2004]
"Yesterday the Khan Yunis City Council named a main street after the
Shahid
Amer Abu Sitta, the chief commander of the Ahmad Abu Al-Rish
Brigades...
"The city council agreed to name the street leading from the Shahid
Ahmad
Yassin Street to the Shahid Cemetery Street in the south, after the
Shahid
Abu Sitta, in light of the Council´s belief in the importance of
these names
in affixing great historical events in the hearts and minds of the
people,
particularly among the younger generation..." [Al-Ayyam, August 10,
2004.
Amer Abu Sitta murdered Israeli citizen Uri Magidish in a terrorist
attack
in the early ´90s. As the commander of the Abu Rish Brigades, Abu
Sitta was
responsible for many terrorist attacks. The terrorist attack against
the
American diplomatic convoy in October 2003 was related to the Abu
Rish
Brigades.]
1.B.3. PA officials and PA TV - March 2005
Glorifying mothers who send sons to Shahada, or death for Allah
Background: Al Khansah archetypal mother of warrior
and Shahids - The ideal Palestinian Woman
Al-Khansah was a poet in the early Islamic period. Before her
conversion to
Islam, her brothers died, and she grieved. Islamic historian Ibn
Athir
writes that after she converted to Islam, she encouraged her four
sons to go
into battle for Allah. When all four were killed, she wrote a poem of
joy -
rejoicing that Allah had honored her with the deaths of her sons.
Al-Khansah is considered the archetypal mother of Shahids, a woman
honored
by Islam for encouraging her sons to kill and die for Allah, and
rejoicing
when they achieved their Shahada deaths.
Al-Khansah and the Palestinian Authority
From a very young age, Palestinian girls are taught to adopt Al-
Khansah as a
role model for her message of celebrating death in combat of Shahids.
The
Palestinian Authority has named at least five girls´ schools "the Al-
Khansah
School for Girls," in:
Bethlehem;
Jenin;
Nablus;
Khan Yunis; and Rafah
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 9, 2005]
A music video for children, broadcast hundreds of times over three
years on
PA TV, included the farewell letter of a child Shahid, including the
words:
"Mother don´t cry for me, be joyous over my blood."
The following are the transcripts of these portrayals of the ideal
Palestinian woman as one who celebrates her son´s death.
1.B.3.1. Friday TV sermon, Sheik Yusuf Juma´ Salamah, Minister of the
Waqf,
in the presence of PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas and other senior PA
members
"Al-Khansah, this noble woman... The day she lost her brother Sakher
[before
she adopted Islam] she began crying, shouting and feeling pain. She
recited
poetry: "The sunrise reminds me of Sakher, and I remember him with
every
sunset, and had there not been around me all the mourners for their
brothers, I would have killed myself". This was during the Jahiliya
[the
pre-Islamic period]. When Allah filled her heart with love for Islam,
and it
became full of faith, things changed. She sent her four sons, her
offspring,
to battle, to Qadisiya [near Iraq] as a service to this religion.
When she
was notified that they had become Shahids, she said, ´Praise Allah,
who
granted me honor with their deaths. I pray that he will take me to
them at
the place where His mercy dwells.´ This is the great woman. This is
the
noble woman. Have you seen how Islam changed her behavior, her
virtues, and
her poetry?" [Official Friday sermon, PA TV, March 11, 2005]
1.B.3.2. Educational TV program "My knowledge, your knowledge"
A young child asks his father: "My father, my father, who is this
woman?"
Father: "This is the poet Tumarid, who is known by name Al-Khansah.
She was
one of the prettiest women of her time..."
Female host: "When [before she adopted Islam] her brother Mu´awiya
died, and
after that her brother on her father´s side, Sakher, she became
extremely
mournful because of them."
Al-Khansah: "I was extremely saddened for Sakher, until my eyes
became
blind. In the Qadisiya battle, four sons of mine became Shahids."
Father: "When she was told of her four sons´ deaths, she pleaded to
the
Creator, to him be the glory and power, and said, "Praise Allah, who
granted
me honor with their deaths."
[PA TV, March 13, 2005]
1.B.3.3. The Dean of Al-Aqsa University Faculty of Media, Dr Hussein
Abu
Shanab [on behalf of the University´s Dean]:
"The Palestinian woman - our hearts are full of respect and
admiration for
her, as she is a unique woman for several reasons: she is the
Shahid´s
mother; and she is the one who shouts for joy on the Day of the
Shahid and
she is the one who shouts for joy, while her son is a prisoner, and
she is
the one who shouts for joy, when her son is arrested..." [PA TV,
March 10,
2005]
1.B.5. PA Ministry of Health
Even the PA Ministry of Health, which is a recipient of USAID money,
has
hospitals named for Shahids, including the Shahid Kamal Adwan
Hospital.
Adwan was one of the commanders of "Black September," which was
responsible
for the murders of 11 Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics,
as well
as the murders of two American diplomats in Sudan.
USAID in the past funded the Shahid Kamal Adwan Hospital directly.
[Al-Ayyam, February 18, 2004].
USAID funds numerous projects of the PA Ministry of Health, which by
definition is honoring terrorists by having hospitals named for
terrorists,
and should therefore not be eligible for US foreign aid.
1.B.6. PA Ministry of Finance
"The Association of the Palestinian Youth [Community] Center
organized a
ceremony in honor of the Shahids of Al-Shaja´iya, and the
inauguration of a
memorial monument [in] "the Shahids´ Square in Al-Shaja´iya. The
inauguration was under the auspices of the Deputy Minister of
Finance, Abu
Osama Muhammad, and in the presence of parliament members...
"The Chairman of the Association´s Board of Directors, Sameh Al-
Wadia, made
a speech, in which he emphasized the importance of the loyalty to the
Shahids and spoke of the anniversary of the Shahids Sallah Khalaf,
Ha´el Abd
Al-Hamid and Fakhri Al-Omari, which took place on the day of the
inauguration of the Shahids´ memorial monument." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida,
February 2, 2005. Abu Iyad, Abu Al-Hol and Abu Muhammad all played
major
roles in planning the murder of Israeli athletes at the Munich
Olympics.]
1.B.7. Presenting the destruction of Israel as justice and the final
stage
of the peace process, with the extermination of Jews as the final
stage of
history
A repeated message in the Palestinian media is that since Israel is
illegitimate, the Oslo agreement is the beginning of the process that
will
result in full justice: the destruction of Israel. The senior PA
salaried
religious leader, Ibrahim Mudayris, explained on PA TV that the goal
of the
diplomatic process - the 1967 borders - was a temporary goal.
The ´return´
to Israeli cities "Haifa, Jaffa, Lod, Ramle, Netanya and Tel Aviv" is
merely
postponed, until later "as Mohammad returned, as a conqueror."
"We tell you Palestine, we shall return to you... We might return to
the
1967 borders by diplomacy, but we won´t return to the 1948 borders
[e.g. the
elimination of Israel] by diplomacy. The 1948 borders - no one on
earth
recognizes as ours. Therefore, we shall return to the 1967 borders,
but we
have not given up on [Israeli cities] Jerusalem, and Haifa, Jaffa,
Lod,
Ramle, Netanya and Tel Aviv. Never. We shall return to every village
we have
been expelled from, by Allah´s will. Why? All the international laws
deny
the Palestinians their real borders. Our approval to return to the
1967
borders is not a concession for our other rights. No...! This
generation
might not achieve this stage, but generations will come, and the land
of
Palestine will demand the Palestinians return as Muhammad returned -
as
conqueror." [PA TV, February 4, 2005]
"The day will come and we shall rule America. The day will come and
we shall
rule Britain, we shall rule the entire world, except the Jews. The
Jews will
not live under our rule agreeably permanently, since they have been
treacherous in nature throughout history. A day will come when all
shall
rest from the Jews, even the tree and the stone, which have suffered
from
them. Listen to your Beloved [Muhammad], who tells you about the
direst
termination of the Jews. The tree and the stone want the Muslim to
bring
every Jew to his end. You all know the Hadith [anticipating the
extermination of the Jews]." [Ibrahim Mudayris, PA TV, May 13, 2005]
2. US Funding
Since the PA is honoring and promoting terrorists as Shahids - the
supreme
honor in PA Islamic teaching - the PA is, according to US law,
ineligible
for direct US funding until it changes the names of all schools,
sport
centers, sporting events and teams, hospitals, etc. that are named
for
terrorists. The PA-owned and controlled daily Al-Hayat Al-Jadida´s
honoring
of the suicide terrorist of February 25, 2005, by defining him as a
Shahid,
and PA TV calls for the destruction of Israel ands extermination of
Jews,
likewise render the PA ineligible for US funding. Many PA
municipalities and
ministries, including the Ministry of Education, Ministry of Heath,
Ministry
of Sport, Ministry of Finance and others are all ineligible for US
funding
because they honor terrorists.
The following are more examples of USAID money illegally going to
Palestinian Authority ministries and infrastructures.
2.1. PA Ministry of Education and Higher Learning
All PA universities have active branches of Hamas and Islamic Jihad
on
campus, and the Ministry of Education has named numerous schools for
terrorists. The Ministry is ineligible for aid under the terms of the
2005
Foreign Operations Bill, yet continues to receive money from the
United
States.
USAID support to universities and PA higher education - $41 Million
Including specifically, Al-Quds, Bir Zeit, Al-Najah and Al-Azhar
universities
"The Minister of Education and Higher Learning, Dr. Naim Abu Al-
Hamtz, met
yesterday with the Director of the US Agency for International
Development
(USAID), James Bever...
"Bever confirmed that the agency continues to support the
sociological-psychological program for students and promised to
support a
new program for higher education, which includes importing equipment
for
faculties and supplies of books and also study guides for the
university
libraries, and in boarding school programs grants for students... The
agreement was signed in collaboration with this institution ... for a
total
of 12 million dollars to aid in the construction of schools." [Al-
Hayat
Al-Jadida, March 10, 2005]
"The Arkan Project, which is controlled by the United States, and the
law
faculties in Al-Najah University signed yesterday an
understanding ... that,
in its framework, establishes collaboration between the two sides for
the
sake of developing law studies...
"The Arkan Project contains two central axes: one is developing law
studies
in Palestinian faculties for law ... in the Al-Quds, Bir Zeit, Al-
Najah and
Al-Azhar universities...
"The Arkan Project will sign, at the beginning of next week, an
understanding similar to Al-Quds University...
"The Project will be carried out by Kamonkas International ... with
the
complete financing of the US Agency for International Development
(USAID)
for a total of about four million dollars." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida,
March 22,
2005]
"The plan to strengthen the ´Arkan law,´ which is controlled by the
United
States, the understanding was signed with Bir Zeit University...
"The project was signed over the course of recent weeks in
understandings
similar to the law faculties in the Al-Azhar, Al-Quds and Al-Najah
universities."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, April 2, 2005]
"This higher education program is part of an initiative of making
quick
improvements at the cost of 41 million dollars, an initiative of the
US
Agency of International Development.
[The components of this program:]
"Three and a half million dollars on new equipment supplies for
technological colleges and vocational training...
"Two and a half million dollars for upgrading computer equipment and
developing programs in twenty colleges...
"The acquisition of books, study-guides, subscriptions for electronic
newspapers and basic data..." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, May 17, 2005]
2.2. Gaza Municipality Road Construction
"The Gaza Municipality began working on the [development] project of
Al-Quds
[Jerusalem] Street, funded by the American Agency for Development
USAID, and
with the assistance of the Local Authority Ministry."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, December 29, 2004]
It should be noted that the Gaza Municipality spent significant funds
from
its budget for road works to rename streets for Shahids and
terrorists. See
Section 1.B.2.1 above.
"The Minister for Local Government, Jamal Al-Shubaki, met yesterday
with the
director of the American Agency for International Development (USAID)
in the
West Bank and Gaza, Jim Beaver, and his delegation, and discussed the
issue
of supplying aid for local committees and municipal elections... As
for the
projects carried out by the American Agency for Development, Shubaki
pointed
out the success of these projects, specifically the road projects..."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 14, 2005]
It should be noted that the PA municipalities have invested from
their
budgets to rename roads for Shahids and terrorists. See Section
1.B.2.1
above.
"Regarding the projects that were performed by the US Agency for
Development, Shubaki indicated the success of these projects,
especially in
the area of the roads." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 14, 2005]
2.3. Sports Centers
"The Khan Yunis municipality completed work in the district sports
center
project...
"The cost of establishing the district sports center was more than
eight
hundred thousand dollars, from financing by several donor
countries ...
[including] the US Agency for International Development." [Al-Hayat
Al-Jadida, February 13, 2005]
3. Palestinian Authority promotion of hatred of America
Despite receiving hundreds of millions of dollars in USAID funding,
the
Palestinian Authority continues to actively disseminate anti-American
sentiment through its official media. Some recent examples follow.
"Where did Great Britain disappear? Where did the Czar´s Russia
disappear?
... In Allah´s will, He will get rid of the USA like he got rid of
them. He
caused Russia to disappear within a day, and He is the one who can
remove
the US and bring it down, and so He shall do it...
"We [Muslims] have ruled the world [in the past] and a day will come,
by
Allah, and we shall rule the world [again]. The day will come and we
shall
rule America. The day will come and we shall rule Britain, we shall
rule the
entire world, except the Jews." [Ibrahim Mudayris, PA salaried Imam,
PA TV,
May 13, 2005]
"The proud Arab Iraqis are dealing with a barbarian invasion machine,
that
has targeted Iraq, the land of Iraq, the people of Iraq, the oil of
Iraq and
the will of the one and only united Arab Iraq...
"We are not terrorists... We are a people that love life and its
land... We
are not attacking anyone. We are a nation that seeks peace, goodness,
lovers
of life, justice and freedom, but nevertheless at the same time we
are a
people that grasps its land and honor until death and beyond...
"Is there aggression against anyone in this? Is there any terrorism,
O
terrorists, cruel [people] and murderers?
"O you who made Arab and Muslim land into a no-man´s land, who burned
Iraq
and the people of Iraq, who stole the oil of Iraq, its treasures and
archeological artifacts, who destroyed the museums of Iraq, its
houses,
culture and economy, who is the [real] terrorist? The Arab, who
defends his
existence and the livelihood of his children, or you, who destroys,
robs,
kills, terrorizes, and causes everything to become disenfranchised
and who
invades...?!
"Be certain, that by your terror and aggression you will not make of
this
nation´s children anything but fighting leaders, and you will acquire
for
your sick souls nothing but shame, dishonor, and the curse of history
for
generations."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 20, 2005]
"The American attack, whose target was the Arab nation living in
Palestine
and Iraq, will be crushed on the rock of the firm stance of our
Palestinian
people, standing firmly and fighting the Jihad in Palestine, and on
the rock
of the strengthening and force of the national resistance in Iraq.
The sun
will rise after the darkness that was spread by the aggressive policy
in the
skies of our Arab homeland.
"The Yankee enemy is treacherous, even if it pretends to be a seeker
of
peace. The occupation remains an occupation and the culture of the
resistance teaches me to resist it, even [if just] by writing of the
deeds
of the enemy."
[Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 27, 2005]
"The United States and the Zionist Entity continue in their dark and
hostile
aggression toward the Arab and Islamic nation in order to eliminate
every
progressive, revolutionary and Jihadi faction within it and,
afterwards, to
subdue it and steal its treasures." [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, March 15,
2005]
"The Muslim remembers, how the Jews corrupted the land... O Muslims!
The
Jews are Jews. Their character and custom are the corruption and
destruction
of this land. We keep warning you: the Jews are a cancer that spreads
inside
the body of the Islamic and Arab nation...
"They invest in the East Asian countries, which were destroyed [by
the
Tsunami] because of the Jewish and American corruption and
destruction."
[Ibrahim Mudayris, PA TV, January 7, 2005]
"Our prisoners are subjected to the most criminal kinds of physical
torture.
They are tied with chains and trussed up with iron chains, and hung
by their
feet from the ceiling, like animals are hung after slaughter for
days. Many
of them lose consciousness. Our prisoners are exposed to beating,
electricity and fire tortures.
"The prisoners are exposed to conversion to Christianity, to
abandoning
religion, [as it was] in the distant past and recently. Yes, our
prisoners
are forced to curse Muhammad; our prisoners are forced to curse the
religion
of Allah, our prisoners are forced to curse the essence of divinity.
"Haven´t you heard of our prisoners in Palestine, have you not heard
of our
prisoners in Iraq, in Afghanistan, and all over the world, who are
exploited
and imprisoned, and are offered conversion to Christianity?
"This is an old - new infidel policy. Allah´s servant, Ibn Al-Hudhafa
Al-Sahmi, totally refused this. The [Christian] Caesar told him: ´We
shall
dip you in boiling oil´. He answered: ´Do as you wish´. He arrived
with two
Muslims and was dipped in boiling oil until his flesh separated from
his
bone. But what the Caesar did was not as bad as what his followers
do, the
missionaries of freedom and democracy of today. In the name of Allah,
what
Caesar did, dipping Muslims in boiling oil, was one hundred thousand
times
lighter than what their soldiers are doing today to our wives and
daughters
in Iraq, in Palestine, in Guantanamo and in Abu Ghraib.
"What Caesar did is not as bad as five American soldiers who meet to
rape
one of our daughters, a girl who has the honor of a Muslim woman, in
order
to desecrate her honor at the Abu Ghraib prison." [Ibrahim Mudayris,
PA
Imam, PA TV, April 15, 2005]
The irony of the PA taking US financial support with one hand while
promoting hatred of the US with the other was strikingly apparent on
May 14
this year. In the PA-owned official daily Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, a half-
page
advertisement was placed by USAID on the very same page that the PA
daily
ran a viciously anti-American cartoon.
Appendix
US 2005 Foreign Operations Bill
PROHIBITION ON ASSISTANCE TO THE PALESTINIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION
SEC. 558. None of the funds appropriated or otherwise made available
by
this Act may be used to provide equipment, technical support,
consulting
services, or any other form of assistance to the Palestinian
Broadcasting
Corporation.
WEST BANK AND GAZA PROGRAM
SEC. 559. (a) OVERSIGHT- For fiscal year 2005, 30 days prior to the
initial
obligation of funds for the bilateral West Bank and Gaza Program, the
Secretary of State shall certify to the appropriate committees of
Congress
that procedures have been established to assure the Comptroller
General of
the United States will have access to appropriate United States
financial
information in order to review the uses of United States assistance
for the
Program funded under the heading ´Economic Support Fund´ for the West
Bank
and Gaza.
(b) VETTING- Prior to the obligation of funds appropriated by this
Act under
the heading ´Economic Support Fund´ for assistance for the West Bank
and
Gaza, the Secretary of State shall take all appropriate steps to
ensure that
such assistance is not provided to or through any individual, private
or
government entity, or educational institution that the Secretary
knows or
has reason to believe advocates, plans, sponsors, engages in, or has
engaged
in, terrorist activity. The Secretary of State shall, as appropriate,
establish procedures specifying the steps to be taken in carrying out
this
subsection and shall terminate assistance to any individual, entity,
or
educational institution which he has determined to be involved in or
advocating terrorist activity.
(c) PROHIBITION- None of the funds appropriated by this Act for
assistance
under the West Bank and Gaza program may be made available for the
purpose
of recognizing or otherwise honoring individuals who commit, or have
committed, acts of terrorism.
(d) AUDITS-
(1) The Administrator of the United States Agency for International
Development shall ensure that Federal or non-Federal audits of all
contractors and grantees, and significant subcontractors and
subgrantees,
under the West Bank and Gaza Program, are conducted at least on an
annual
basis to ensure, among other things, compliance with this section.
(2) Of the funds appropriated by this Act under the heading ´Economic
Support Fund´ that are made available for assistance for the West
Bank and
Gaza, up to $1,000,000 may be used by the Office of the Inspector
General of
the United States Agency for International Development for audits,
inspections, and other activities in furtherance of the requirements
of this
subsection. Such funds are in addition to funds otherwise available
for such
purposes. (PMW.0RG.IL 06/24/05)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY