´What right did they have?´ (JERUSALEM POST) By GREER FAY CASHMAN AUSCHWITZ-BIRKENAU 01/28/05)
Source: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull&cid=1106848123545
JERUSALEM POST
JERUSALEM POST Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Of the more than 40 world leaders present for Thursday´s ceremony
commemorating the 60th anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz-
Birkenau camp, it was an Auschwitz survivor who stole the show.
Of the more than 40 world leaders present for Thursday´s ceremony
commemorating the 60th anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz-
Birkenau camp, it was an Auschwitz survivor who stole the show.
As President Moshe Katsav, the first foreign dignitary to address the
gathering, was winding up his speech, a woman sitting in the rows of
survivors got up from her seat and walked over to the speakers´
podium, where she stood, waiting with arms folded until Katsav
finished talking.
Auschwitz survivor Miriam Yahav (previously Merka Szevach), who was
not listed on the program to speak, then jumped onto the podium and
positioned herself in front of the microphone.
Grabbing the spotlight for a few seconds, she asked why she, an
innocent 16-year-old, had been brought to this place and reduced to
something less than human.
"They took away my name and gave me a number. I was no longer Merka
Szevach. What right did they have to kill my family? What right did
they have to kill my people?" she asked. "Why? Why did they do that,
and why did they burn my whole family here?"
Then, calming down somewhat, Yahav, who now lives in Israel, added
proudly: "I now have a country, an army and a president."
On one side of the huge expanse set aside in Birkenau, a group of
survivors sat wearing blue-and-white striped neckbands and wristbands
symbolic of the uniforms worn by camp inmates. Standing on a chain in
the center of the huge gathering, at the focus of attention, a young
man wore a blue-and-white Israeli flag draped like a cape over his
back and shoulders.
The two sets of blue and white – in this barbaric place that is the
largest Jewish graveyard in the world – reflected the transition from
humiliation to pride, from fear to fearlessness and courage.
Elsewhere, others held up Israeli flags, but none made as powerful an
impact as that worn by the young man.
Birkenau is enormous; the walk from the entrance to the crematoria
alone takes 15 minutes. Most of the thousands of people who came and
made that walk yesterday arrived early. Many were elderly. They sat
for more than three hours in the freezing cold, waiting for the
ceremony to begin – and then they sat for another three hours until
it was over. Many of the survivors were also pained by the sound of
the train which so many years earlier had brought them to Auschwitz.
Most of the dignitaries delivered speeches similar in content,
recalling Nazi atrocites and the suffering of people from many
places, most of all that of the Jews. Katsav spoke in the same vein,
but injected an added emotion and accusation.
"It seems if you listen hard enough, you can still hear the outcry of
horror of the murdered people," he declared. "When I walk the ground
of the concentration camps, I fear that I am walking on the ashes of
the victims."
While primarily castigating the Germans, Katsav did not spare those
European nations that allowed the Nazis to turn so much of the
continent into a killing field. Directly addressing the assembled
leaders of Europe, Katsav said, "More than a million Jews were
murdered – all of them sons and daughters of your lands, citizens of
your countries.
"We know that Europe was occupied by the Nazi regime, but we also
remember that there was rabid anti-Semitism in Europe, leaving Jews
with no escape and no hope. The world knew of the destruction of
European Jewry and remained silent."
Katsav also noted the hesitation on the part of the Allies to bomb
the death camps and to destroy the railways on which Jews were
transported to the death camps.
"This too remains a stain on humanity," he said.
Pointing to the reemergence of anti-Semitisim in Europe, Katsav
warned world leaders to beware of the dangerous doctrines that could
once again plunge the world into murderous fanatacism. Noting that
Israel is only a three-hour flight away, and that survivors, despite
their suffering, had succeeded in building their ancestral homeland
into a modern vibrant democracy, Katsav also spoke to the souls of
those who did not survive.
"My brothers and sisters, the martyrs of the Shoah, who were not able
to join the State of Israel," he said, "world leaders have come to
this place which was your hell in order to remember you. You are the
lost citizens of our homeland."
The leaders, including presidents Aleksander Kwasniewski of Poland,
Russia´s Vladimir Putin and France´s Jacques Chirac, filed out
placing candles, shielded in blue lanterns against the freezing wind,
on a low stone memorial. Vice President Dick Cheney represented the
United States.
Putin compared Nazis to today´s terrorists.
"Today we shall not only remember the past but also be aware of all
the threats of the modern world. Terrorism is among them, and it is
no less dangerous and cunning than fascism," he said.
Cheney said earlier at a youth forum in Krakow that the camps remind
the world evil must be confronted.
"We are reminded that anti-Semitism may begin with words but rarely
stops with words and the message of intolerance and hatred must be
opposed before it turns into acts of horror," he said.
Germany´s President Horst Koehler placed a candle but didn´t speak,
in recognition of Germany´s responsibility for the Holocaust.
Before the ceremony, Koehler toured the camp complex with former
inmates.
"We have the duty to ensure that something like this never happens
again – we Germans in particular," he said. "We still have a lot of
work to do."
The ceremony at Birkenau began with the recorded rumble of a train at
the place where new arrivals stumbled out of cattle cars and were met
by Nazi doctors who chose a few to be worked to death, and had the
rest sent immediately to the gas chambers. It ended with a recorded
train whistle sounding over loudspeakers.
It was already dark when the ceremony concluded with a dramatic
candlelight procession led by heads of delegations. The crowd
dispersed and made its way back. But in one of the barracks, a light
was burning; some of the former inmates had gathered inside. They
were singing Hatikva. AP contributed to this report. (© 1995-2005,
The Jerusalem Post 01/28/05)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY