Whitewashing a Dictator (FrontPageMagazine.com) by Bruce Bawer 08/13/12)
Source: http://frontpagemag.com/2012/bruce-bawer/whitewashing-a-dictator/
Front Page Magazine.com
Front Page Magazine.com Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
During the last few days I’ve been reading and watching various items
online about Leon H. Sullivan (1922-2001), a leader of the civil-
rights movement and a mentor to Martin Luther King, Jr. As you can
see in this short video about him, Sullivan, who was awarded the
Presidential Medal of Freedom by George H.W. Bush and the Eleanor
Roosevelt Award for Human Rights by Bill Clinton, preached “hard-work
and self-help.” Neither a Marxist nor a Black Power agitator,
Sullivan, who spent twenty years on the board of General Motors,
sought to improve the conditions of underprivileged black people both
in the United States and in Africa through a range of ambitious and
apparently well-run programs involving education, investment, medical
care, and business development. To all indications, he was a man of
honor, principle, and serious dedication. And until recently, I’m
embarrassed to say, I didn’t know the first thing about him. (If I
ever did, I’d long since forgotten it.) Meanwhile – such, alas, is
the way these things have turned out – we all know the names, faces,
and voices of hucksters like Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton.
The occasion for my belated self-education in the life and career of
Leon H. Sullivan was an unpleasant one. As it turns out, there
exists something called the Leon H. Sullivan Foundation. Its offices
are in Washington, D.C.; its president is Sullivan’s daughter, Hope
Sullivan Masters; and the chairman of its board is Andrew Young,
former mayor of Atlanta and U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations
under Jimmy Carter. Over the years, the foundation has held a series
of “Sullivan Summits” in various African countries on the subject of
human rights; the ninth summit is scheduled to take place later this
month in the west African country of Equatorial Guinea under the
sponsorship, and with the financial backing, of that country’s
president, Teodoro Obiang.
On August 1, Thor Halvorssen and George Ayittey of the New York-based
Human Rights Foundation sent a letter to Masters and Young expressing
concern about these plans, noting that Obiang is a “dictator who
heads one of the world’s most repressive regimes and is accused of
carrying out crimes against humanity.” In power since 1979, Obiang
has been re-elected over and over again by ridiculous margins in sham
elections, and during his tenure (the longest of any non-royal on
earth) has established a Stalin-style cult of personality, with the
state-owned media describing him as a god.
As if that weren’t enough, Obiang would also appear to be the very
personification of kleptocratic corruption. Although Equatorial
Guinea, thanks to its oil wealth, has a per capita income of $36,515,
placing it on a level with Western Europe, most of its people are
among the continent’s most destitute, earning an average of less than
two dollars a day and enduring the most primitive imaginable excuse
for an infrastructure. “Here is a country where people should have
the per capita wealth of Spain or Italy, but instead they live in
poverty worse than in Afghanistan or Chad,” a Human Rights Watch
official told the New York Times in 2009. “This is a testament to the
government’s corruption, mismanagement and callousness toward its own
people.” Last October an Observer piece headlined “The strange and
evil world of Equatorial Guinea” painted a horrific portrait of
engineers and economists living in dilapidated shacks, of schools
that are muddy sheds without books, and of children growing up in
brutal prisons.
Where does all the money go? Mostly, it would appear, to Obiang and
his family. The other day Jon Perdue noted in the Washington Times
that by 2003, Obiang had reportedly “become the biggest depositor of
the infamous Riggs Bank, with $700 million in its U.S. account, ‘some
of it hauled $1 million at a time into Riggs’s [Dupont] Circle branch
in shrink-wrapped, 20-pound bundles.’” Obiang’s son, Teodorin, who
was his country’s Minister of Agriculture and Forestry and is now
vice-president and heir presumptive to the dictatorship, has “$10
million party weekends and dozens of high-end cars and homes around
the world.” There’s currently a warrant out for him in France, where
last year authorities confiscated his personal fleet of luxury cars;
meanwhile the U.S. Justice Department is looking to seize his
Gulfstream jet and other properties, including his Malibu beach
house, which is said to have the most highly assessed property value
in that city.
In their letter to Masters and Young, Halvorssen and Ayittey spelled
out many of the horrors of Obiang’s regime, and added a few telling
statistics: the country “scores a zero on the Open Budget Index, and
is listed 172 out of 182 in Transparency International’s Corruption
Perception Index. Reporters Without Borders ranks it 161 out of 179
in their Press Freedom Index, and the Committee to Protect
Journalists considers it the fifth most censored country in the
world.” And yet, Halvorssen and Ayittey pointed out, “the Sullivan
Foundation has not once made reference to this appalling and well-
documented record of corruption and human rights abuse.” On the
contrary, the Sullivan Foundation has mendaciously claimed that
Equatorial Guinea under Obiang has enjoyed “political pluralism”
and “good governance” and developed a “civil society.” The
foundation boasts of Equatorial Guinea’s per capita income – but
omits to mention that “none of that wealth is shared beyond the
rulers of this police state.” As if that weren’t enough, the
Sullivan Foundation honored Obiang last December with a human-rights
award. Noting that all of this was utterly contrary to the legacy of
Leon Sullivan, Halvorssen and Ayittey called on Masters and Young to
cancel the summit.
Halvorssen and Ayittey’s letter attracted widespread attention (as
did their article about this travesty that appeared in the Wall
Street Journal on August 8). Around the world, people familiar with
Sullivan’s legacy expressed shock at the cozy relationship that
appears to exist between the Sullivan Foundation and the Obiang
dictatorship. What, many wondered, would Sullivan have made of this
spectacle? The attention had some effect: the summit’s keynote
speaker canceled, as did others who had apparently planned to
attend. The name of Bill Clinton, who had been identified on the
organization’s website as an honorary chairman, suddenly and
mysteriously disappeared. And Andrew Young, in a curious response to
a letter from the Human Rights Foundation, claimed that he is no
longer chairman of the Sullivan Foundation (even though he is
identified as such on its website) and added that he has “not
attended Sullivan Foundation Board meetings in 2012” and
consequently “was not a party to the decision to hold the Summit in
Equatorial Guinea” – a decision announced, note well, in 2011.
Yet Masters, far from changing her tune, shot back at her critics on
August 6 in a semi-literate blog post in which she avoided all the
matters of substance that they had raised and instead played the –
um – postcolonialism card. How dare these Westerners criticize
Obiang, whose people had made him their president and whose fellow
African leaders had picked him to lead the African Union? “For
centuries,” she thundered, “Africa has been exploited, denigrated,
and treated as the habitat of people of inferior intellect…. It would
appear that some would still like to be in the position of
controlling the people and the resources of Africa.” As if she
feared that she wasn’t making her point obvious enough, she spelled
it out in a tweet (later deleted): “Racism is alive and well.” On
August 10, in the face of rising criticism, she posted a You Tube
video – also semi-literate – reaffirming her determination to go
ahead with the summit.
I may be wrong, but from what I have read and seen about Leon
Sullivan, he would have been repulsed by the now-familiar argument
that the way tyrants treat their subjects in a non-Western country is
no business of Westerners – that the history of Western colonialism
compels Westerners to keep their mouths shut about even the most
egregious human-rights abuses in former Western colonies. Certainly
there’s no question that he’d be appalled by the shady dealings that
his daughter’s feeble attempt at a cultural-relativist smokescreen
seem designed to obscure. As Joe Kraus of the human-rights group
Equatorial Guinea Justice charges, the Sullivan Foundation is “being
used to launder the image of the world’s longest-serving ruler”; or,
to quote Halvorssen, the foundation “appears to be running a
disinformation campaign for a dictator.” In return, apparently, that
dictator is bankrolling the foundation, which, according to U.S. News
and World Report, is desperately in need of the dough. The level of
support is such that the Equatoguinean summit is even being
advertised on buses in Washington, D.C. linking Obiang’s dictatorship
with Leon H. Sullivan’s name. (It is interesting to note, by the
way, that the Leon H. Sullivan Foundation was not founded by
Sullivan: instead, he founded an Arizona-based group that apparently
does in practice what the Sullivan Foundation claims to do in its
mission statement.)
If things are as they seem to be, then, Hope Sullivan Masters has
made the ultimate deal with the devil: in exchange for cold, hard
cash, she’s using the cachet of her father’s name to give one of the
world’s most savage governments a squeaky-clean human-rights image –
briefly put, she’s lining her pockets by running a propaganda
operation for a thug. If this is indeed what’s going on here,
Masters is committing a multiple betrayal: she’s besmirching her
father’s heroic legacy; she’s doing something that will, to some
degree, and in some quarters, taint the image of all human-rights
organizations; and, most important, she’s cynically and selfishly
trampling on the already trampled people of Equatorial Guinea, whose
greatest hope for the future lies with groups, such as the Human
Rights Foundation, that actually care about them. (Copyright © 2012
FrontPageMagazine.com 08/13/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY