Arab Envoys Rebuked for Denying Prize Money to Algerian Writer (NY) TIMES) By MAÏA de la BAUME PARIS, FRANCE 07/05/12)
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/05/world/europe/arab-envoys-rebuked-for-denying-prize-money-to-algerian-writer.html
NEW YORK TIMES
NEW YORK TIMES Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
PARIS — Arab diplomats in France have been sharply criticized for
quietly withdrawing the prize money for a literary award because the
winner, a famous Algerian novelist, visited Israel, with many here
denouncing what they call an unacceptable incursion of politics into
art.
The anger has been building in the French press since the award,
minus the prize money, was handed out by a publishing company last
month instead. The head of the jury resigned temporarily in protest.
The group of 22 diplomats under fire, who are from Arab League
nations and have sponsored the prize for three years, said little,
except that they were following the policies of their countries,
which remain in a formal state of war with Israel.
The winner, Boualem Sansal, 63, a former engineer who began writing
novels at 50 and became highly acclaimed, was scheduled to receive
the Prix du Roman Arabe (the Arab Novel Prize) for his book “Rue
Darwin” (“Darwin Street”). But in May, he spoke at a literary
festival in Israel, and afterward Hamas, the Palestinian Islamist
group that runs Gaza, said he had committed “an act of treason
against the Palestinian people.”
Arab ambassadors based in Paris later wrote the jury that they had
decided to cancel the ceremony and withdraw the 15,000 euros in prize
money, about $19,000, “due to the current events in the Arab world.”
Mr. Sansal was incensed. “The Arab ambassadors have no right to
behave in such way,” he said in a telephone interview on Tuesday from
Boumerdès, a city near Algiers where he lives. “Those people don’t
respect anything, especially the country they live in.”
Describing his time in Israel, he said he had been a guest of the
third International Writers Festival in Jerusalem and had spoken
about Israeli settlements on a panel with Israeli authors. He said he
had described the settlements as an element of occupation and not as
a “colony.” In general, the French use the word “colonists” to
describe the settlers.
An official at the Arab League office in Paris, insisting on
anonymity, said that “the ambassadors stopped sponsoring the prize
after Mr. Sansal went to Israel, where he said that the colonization
of occupied territory was nonexistent.”
Mr. Sansal denied that characterization and objected that his words
were being twisted.
“I can’t express myself, as if I didn’t exist,” Mr. Sansal said. “But
the future belongs to us, the military dictatorships in the Arab
world are gone, the Islamists will go. The world needs stability and
clarity.”
The head of the jury that awarded the prize, Olivier Poivre d’Arvor,
director of France Culture radio, resigned in an open letter, calling
the link between the Hamas statement and the withdrawal of the prize
money “a sordid truth.”
He wrote that “between being nominated for the prize and actually
receiving it, Boualem Sansal visited Israel.”
“Hamas immediately issued a statement calling his presence an act of
treason against the Palestinians,” Mr. Poivre d’Arvor continued. “The
reaction of Arab Ambassadors Council was a direct result of this.”
On June 21, Mr. Sansal was finally given the award, but without the
money, at a small symbolic ceremony at the headquarters of his
publisher, Gallimard.
But the diplomats’ decision to cancel the award ceremony and withdraw
the prize money prompted members of the jury, authors and a prominent
Jewish organization, the Representative Council of Jewish
Organizations of France, or CRIF, to denounce the intrusion of
politics into literature.
“If we needed additional evidence of the regressive imprisonment the
Arab world is now plunging into, we find it is in this lamentable
behavior,” said an editorial recently posted on the CRIF Web site.
Members of the jury, who include the Moroccan novelist Tahar Ben
Jelloun, said that the prize would continue to exist and announced
that new sponsors would be sought.
Mr. Sansal has been a critic of the military government in Algeria,
where his books have been censored. In 2008, he compared Islamism to
Nazism in his book called “Le Village de l’Allemand ou Le Journal des
Frères Schiller” (“The Village of the German or The Diary of the
Schiller Brothers”), which describes the life of a Nazi officer who
becomes a hero of the National Liberation Front, now Algeria’s
governing party. (Copyright 2012 The New York Times Company 07/05/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY