Op-Ed: Forget About a Palestinian State (INN) ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS) Dovid Efune, Dir. Algemeiner Journal 06/27/12)
Source: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Articles/Article.aspx/11840#.T-vaXxdo2uk
INN} ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS
INN} ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Ron Lauder published an ad on the lines of Netanyahu´s speech in
which he offered a state to the PA Arabs. Think again. A lot has
changed since that speech.
Rockets are still raining down on Israeli cities and towns. From Gaza
the attacks have been sporadic and at other times accelerated,
presenting a continuous and looming threat. Over 290 projectiles have
been fired at the Jewish state since the beginning of 2012, including
eight which were launched in a one hour period on Tuesday. The range
of the more advanced missiles is up to thirty miles, according to the
Israel Defense Forces.
Many have documented the debilitating effect that this state of
affairs has on day to day living, commerce and the building of
communities, families and workplaces. Not to mention the trauma
suffered by those individuals whose lives, homes or loved ones have
been caught in the crosshairs of one or more attacks.
The highly acclaimed ‘Iron Dome’ missile defense system seems to
have blunted the impact of the attacks, this combined with what the
IDF refers to as other components of defense, namely, “active
targeting of rocket launching squads and passive defenses, such as
bomb shelters.”
However, when it comes to charting a path for Israel to secure the
safety of its citizens, it is crucial to consider the wider regional
context of this threat and its capacity to develop significantly.
Firstly, it is well known that Hizbullah in the North, essentially in
control of Lebanon, has an immense arsenal trained on Israel.
According to a U.S. Embassy cable released by Wikileaks in November,
Israeli officials noted that “rockets from Lebanon can now cover the
entire territory of Israel.” A UPI report from March 2009 quoted
Israeli Government Officials who estimated that over 50,000 missiles
are targeted at Israel between Hamas and Hizbullah.
On Friday night, two rockets were fired into Israel’s south by a
terrorist cell operating in Egypt’s Sinai desert. A terror assault
following on Monday morning that left one civilian dead, prompted IDF
Chief of Staff Benny Gantz to tour the southern border where he said
that a “significant issue is what goes on in Sinai, where terror
bases continue to form.”
News sources reported that the IDF is considering hooking up the city
of Eilat to early-warning systems that would alert residents of
incoming rocket attacks. Previously it was said on Israeli news that
the IDF was preparing a launch site for the Iron Dome rocket-defense
system near Eilat ahead of the possibility that the system will be
deployed there in the future.”
The increasing threat from Sinai means that of the six territories
that are within firing distance of Israel three of them are actively
serving as launch pads of Arab aggression against the country.
Of great concern to Israel is the that the genesis of this status quo
was similar in all three cases, namely through the enactment of some
process of democratization, or more accurately, as Brett Stephens of
the Wall Street Journal described it in his Tuesday column entitled
The Decline of Democracy, “the energetic stirrings of pre-liberal
democracy,” which he defines as “democracy shorn of the values
Westerners typically associate with it: free speech, religious
liberty, social tolerance, equality between the sexes and so on.”
In Egypt this was a product of the Arab Spring, in Gaza, Hamas’ rise
to control began with democracy style elections and in Lebanon,
Hizbullah’s grip on power was solidified through the parliamentary
process. Along these lines, when looking at Israel’s remaining three
close neighbors, the chances of this nightmare scenario developing
further must be considered.
Syria in the north is in the throes of a civil war, the outcome of
which remains to be seen. As in previous cases, it is entirely
possible that the power vacuum that could be created by Assad’s
eventual removal would allow for terror groups to pitch themselves on
the Syria-Israel border establishing another stronghold for rocket
launching, within range of vulnerable Israeli farms and wineries.
Israel’s longest and most stable border is with Jordan to the east,
and although to a much lesser degree, discontent has been brewing
there for some time. Last month the Washington Post reported on “deep
and growing tensions that call into question the stability of this
strategically significant kingdom of 6 million people, a bedrock of
U.S. influence in the region and Israel’s last reliable Arab ally
since the fall of Egypt’s Hosni Mubarak.” Surely Israel must consider
the possibility of change in Jordan allowing for the propagation of
more hostile forces on this front.
To Israel’s south east lies the vast kingdom of Saudi Arabia, whose
far northwestern corner is within upgraded grad rocket range of
Israel’s southern port city of Eilat. The oil rich state is also seen
to be relatively stable, but according to Karen Elliott House writing
for the Wall Street Journal on Monday, “The death and burial this
weekend of Saudi Crown Prince Nayef, the second Saudi crown prince to
die in less than a year, demonstrates the inherent instability of the
absolute monarchy still being ruled by the geriatric sons of the
founder of modern Saudi Arabia.” She Concludes, “Clearly, a growing
number of frustrated Saudis no longer either respect or fear their
leaders. Saudis are not demanding democracy; only transparent,
efficient, honest government.”
It is true that Israel has developed some tools for dealing with
these threats, but they are very limited - especially if the country
came under fire from every single land border. Militarily responding
to these attacks emanating from urban neighborhoods will inevitably
result in civilian deaths leading to unilateral foreign condemnation
of the Jewish state and near diplomatic isolation. The Iron Dome
system is super expensive and if demanded to such an extent
prohibitively so. Either way, as the Lebanon Daily Star pointed out
in March, “Iron Dome cannot reverse the strategic problem posed even
by the relatively unsophisticated Qassam and Katyusha rockets from
Gaza – the disruption of normal life in Israel.” Of course the
economic impact of this could be crippling.
Considering the above, Israel’s leaders would have to be insane to
consider parting with any of the real estate whatsoever demanded by
the PLO for the establishment of a state that would surely be highly
susceptible to the type of ‘progress’ that brought about the
entrenchment of a mega arsenal on Israel’s other borders.
In truth, those that today are insistent in their calls for the
establishment of a Palestinian State are simply cheerleaders for
Israel’s demise. Israel must always control the West Bank if it is
to survive (IsraelNationalNews © 2012 06/27/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY