Strategy to combat delegitimization good, could be better (JERUSALEM POST OP-ED) By JASON EDELSTEIN 06/20/12)
Source: http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Op-EdContributors/Article.aspx?id=274472
JERUSALEM POST
JERUSALEM POST Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
As leaders from Jewish communities around the world gather in
Jerusalem for the Presidential Conference, strategies to defeat the
efforts aimed at depriving Israel of legitimacy will again be
examined.
For more than 10 years – since the 2001 UN World Conference Against
Racism in Durban, South Africa – the leaders of this war have
exploited human rights rhetoric and international legal claims to
push their objective to eliminate Israel as the nation state of the
Jewish people. Their strategy is to portray Israel as
an “apartheid,” “racist” and “colonial” state that is so “criminal”
that it is beyond rehabilitation. The message is driven by and is
echoed through hundreds of NGOs, creating a very dangerous moral
atmosphere.
The “vehicle of choice” to pursue this strategy is the global BDS –
boycott, divestment and sanctions – campaign, which is being pushed
in communities and on university campuses around the world. This
campaign, and the overall strategy, also targets and isolates
supporters of Israel.
Sabeel, a pro-BDS, anti-Semitic NGO that promotes Palestinian
liberation theology, hosted a conference at which an activist
admitted that “the actual goal of divestment and the broader BDS
movement is to isolate Israel, and make it embarrassing to support
Israel.” Often, in local Jewish communities, fringe anti-Israel
groups with “Jewish” in their names provide cover for these types of
extreme anti-Israel campaigners, including those that use anti-
Semitic rhetoric.
In this, it is critical to engage with individuals and groups that
have lent their names to this cause, sometimes without understanding
the goals. The Israel Action Network has begun significant work in
this regard, developing alliances with key labor unions that are
targeted or co-opted by the delegitmization campaign.
Ending this passive support for BDS is an important step towards
marginalizing the NGOs that promote these campaigns.
IN ADDITION, when these NGOs and the BDSers invade campuses, Jewish
students and local communities have strategically organized to fight
BDS resolutions in their student unions. Similarly, when the
demonizers publicize calls for boycotts at local food co-ops, the
community responds.
But, in this war, it is necessary to change the main tactics and
strategy from reactive to proactive, in order to undermine the
credibility and influence of the NGO engines that drive the attack.
This strategy will expose the fringe and anti- Semitic nature of many
of the BDS movement’s central actors, and expose the lie that BDS is
a grassroots protest against Israeli policy.
The fact is that hundreds of millions of dollars over the past decade
from both European governments and private donations have gone to
hundreds of NGOs that sustain and advance this campaign.
The powerful NGO campaigns of false allegations targeting Israel
creates the environment where NGO delegitimization events occur
almost daily. On June 6, for example, Amnesty International published
a report accusing Israel of wrongdoing regarding administrative
detention of terror suspects.
Although the claims were entirely unsubstantiated, based on
unverifiable information, and comprised largely of a one-sided
Palestinian narrative, it was immediately highlighted in the
international media.
While the Israeli government and major pro-Israel organizations were
made aware of this report’s impending release, they were still unable
to effectively counter the onslaught of entirely predictable negative
media coverage.
Reactions, which are tactical, are becoming somewhat more effective
in combating BDS, but the counterattacks remain insufficient.
To win this war, these resources need to be focused intelligently on
naming and shaming the promoters of demonization that exploit human
rights, as well as their funders, particularly in European
governments.
The writer is communications director of NGO Monitor, a Jerusalem-
based research institution dedicated to promoting universal human
rights and to encouraging civil discussion on the reports and
activities of nongovernmental organizations, particularly in the
Middle East. (© 1995-2011, The Jerusalem Post 06/20/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY