Powers want "diamonds for peanuts": Iran ex-official (REUTERS) By Fredrik Dahl VIENNA, AUSTRIA 06/15/12 3:09pm EDT)
Source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/15/us-nuclear-iran-demands-idUSBRE85E19O20120615
Reuters News Service
Reuters News Service Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
(Reuters) - A former Iranian negotiator on Friday dismissed
as "diamonds for peanuts" a proposal by world powers that Tehran halt
higher-grade uranium enrichment and close an underground nuclear site
in exchange for reactor fuel and civil aviation parts.
Hossein Mousavian, now a visiting scholar at Princeton University in
the United States, said he did not believe Iran would accept the
offer when the two sides hold a new round of discussions in Moscow on
June 18-19.
It will be the third meeting since diplomacy restarted in April after
a 15-month hiatus.
"I do not expect too much," said Mousavian, a senior member of Iran´s
nuclear negotiating team in 2003-05.
If the major powers are not ready to move on the critical issues of
gradually removing sanctions on Iran and recognizing its right to
refine uranium, "I´m afraid the Moscow talks also would fail," he
told Reuters in a telephone interview.
Mousavian held his post before conservative President Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad took over from his reformist predecessor Mohammad Khatami
in 2005. Western envoys who know Mousavian say that at the time he
appeared to be genuinely interested in reaching a deal with the West.
The six powers - the United States, France, Germany, Britain, China
and Russia - want to make sure Iran does not develop nuclear bombs.
The Islamic Republic wants a lifting of sanctions and recognition of
what it says are its rights to peaceful nuclear energy, including
enriching uranium.
European Union officials said on Monday that Iran had agreed to
discuss a proposal to curb its production of higher-grade uranium at
the meeting in the Russian capital, an apparent attempt to reduce
tensions ahead of the talks.
The development followed more than two weeks of wrangling between
Iranian diplomats and Western negotiators over preparations for the
closely watched round of negotiations.
Mousavian said Iran was ready for a "big deal" on the decade-old
nuclear dispute, but political constraints in the United States ahead
of November´s presidential election and other factors meant the other
side was not.
"President Obama has very limited room to maneuver in an election
year," Mousavian said. Barack Obama´s Republican opponents have
attempted to paint him as soft on enemies of the United States.
"DELIBERATELY UNGENEROUS"
In the immediate term, the powers want Tehran to cease enriching
uranium to 20 percent fissile concentration, because such production
represents a major technological advance en route to making weapons-
grade material.
They put forward a proposal on how to achieve this at a round of
talks in Baghdad in May, in which Tehran would stop production, close
the Fordow underground facility where such work is done, and ship its
stockpile out of the country.
In return, they offered to supply the Islamic state with fuel for a
medical research reactor in Tehran, which requires 20-percent
uranium, and to ease sanctions against the sale of commercial
aircraft parts to Iran.
No agreement was reached in Baghdad but the seven countries agreed to
continue discussions in Moscow.
"I believe this is diamonds for peanuts," Mousavian said, adding that
Iran already had fuel rods. "Therefore this is not something great to
offer Iran."
The International Crisis Group think-tank said the powers´ offer "was
deliberately ungenerous" and likely to have been meant as an opening
bid in what they regarded as a longer process of negotiations.
But a U.S. nuclear expert, David Albright, said Mousavian´s comments
showed the "difficulty of negotiating" with Iran.
The agreement sought by the powers in Moscow would be a small but
important step which does not solve the Iran nuclear issue, said
Albright, of the Institute for Science and International Security
(ISIS) think tank.
"Iran should expect only a small incentive in return ... the fact of
the matter is that these actions are equivalent to peanuts for
peanuts," Albright said in an email.
Mousavian said, however, that Iran was ready for confidence-building
measures regarding its enrichment of uranium to 20 percent, which it
started in 2010 and has since expanded.
He said his own proposal was that Iran would agree to eliminate such
material from its stockpile, either by converting it to fuel,
exporting it or lowering its enrichment concentration to 3.5 percent -
the level usually required for power plants. (Editing by Rosalind
Russell) (© Thomson Reuters 2012. 06/15/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY