Members Login
New Members Sign-Up
Top Boards
1)
Israel hails US call...
2)
Egypt admits wounded...
3)
Obama´s opportu...
4)
Palestinians fire ro...
5)
Israel, Palestinians...
6)
Israel not honoring ...
7)
Gaza Smugglers Ready...
8)
Saudi Asks Israel to...
9)
Israel’s Political S...
10)
Mideast peace takes ...
Home
>
Israel-News Today
New Egypt constitution body faces fresh challenge (REUTERS) By Yasmine Saleh CAIRO, EGYPT 06/13/12 12:43pm EDT)
Source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/13/us-egypt-constitution-idUSBRE85C12H20120613
The Headline Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
* Members login now to write a Letter to the Editor
* Choose from 1 of the 4 descriptions for the headline and or any paragraph.
* Not a member click here join now
(Reuters) - Egypt´s parliament has for the second time approved an assembly to draft a new constitution after the first attempt was criticized for including too many Islamists.
Paragraph-1 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
But the list of 100 names immediately triggered similar objections from liberals and Christians, raising the prospect of fresh legal challenges to the new assembly in the courts - the latest hurdle in Egypt´s bumpy transition to democracy.
Paragraph-2 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The delays mean the new president will not know the extent of his powers when he is elected in a run-off vote this weekend.
Paragraph-3 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Islamists hold about two-thirds of the seats in parliament, leading to fears among liberals that they will again be sidelined in the new Egypt, despite their contribution to the overthrow of Hosni Mubarak´s military-backed autocracy last year.
Paragraph-4 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The presidential run-off adds to those fears, pitting Mohamed Mursi, a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, against Ahmed Shafik, a former air force general who was Mubarak´s last prime minister.
Paragraph-5 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The main parties in parliament said last week they had reached agreement on the shape of the constitutional assembly, and both houses approved the list late on Tuesday.
Paragraph-6 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
"This assembly saw many twists that hindered it for some time, but in the end it was formed to represent all Egyptian groups," parliamentary speaker Saad al-Katatni told a joint session of both houses.
Paragraph-7 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Katatni, who resigned from the Muslim Brotherhood´s party to take the speaker´s post, said the list included 33 people from political parties including members of parliament, as well as constitutional experts, judicial figures, Christian and Muslim clerics, union members and representatives of the army, police, government and Egypt´s youth.
Paragraph-8 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
However, some liberal and independent members walked out in protest on Tuesday before the final agreement, saying the list would under- represent women, intellectuals, and the Christians who make up a 10th of Egypt´s 82 million people.
Paragraph-9 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Amen Eskander, a member of parliament for the Al-Karama Party, said there would be too many Islamists in the assembly, "just like in the previous one".
Paragraph-10 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Egypt´s Coptic Orthodox, Anglican and Catholic churches withdrew their representatives from the first assembly, but have so far indicated they will remain in the latest one. Together those churches secured seven seats.
Paragraph-11 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Egypt´s prestigious al-Azhar seat of Sunni learning has five seats. It also withdrew from the first body in solidarity with liberals, churches and others.
Paragraph-12 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
HANDOVER OF POWER
Paragraph-13 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The ruling generals have pledged to hand power to a new president by July 1 as the climax of almost a year and a half of messy and often bloody transition to civilian rule, but the failure to establish a clear path towards a new constitution suggests more turbulence ahead.
Paragraph-14 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
All sides agree to the principle that the constitutional assembly should reflect a broad cross-section of society, but Islamists and liberals have argued about how the process is implemented in practice.
Paragraph-15 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Egyptians want above all a constitution that distributes power more fairly than the one that underpinned Mubarak´s rule.
Paragraph-16 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Among the issues likely to stir most debate are the extent of presidential and parliamentary powers and the degree to which Islamic law, or sharia, will be applied.
Paragraph-17 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The deal reached last week said there would be a broad 50-50 liberal- Islamist split in the assembly.
Paragraph-18 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
But rifts emerged almost at once when liberals accused the Islamists of filling the nominal liberal contingent with people from Islamic ideological backgrounds, such as Muslim clerics from al-Azhar.
Paragraph-19 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Liberal and leftist parties said on Monday they would renounce their seats in the new assembly.
Paragraph-20 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
One member of parliament who withdrew, Abul Ezz el-Hariry, said he would challenge the new list in court.
Paragraph-21 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Hariry, a presidential candidate who fell out of the race in the first round last month, was among a group of liberals and lawyers who successfully challenged the first assembly in April.
Paragraph-22 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
"An assembly in which Egyptians do not see themselves (represented) is the end of a transition in which they have been trying to kill the revolution and confiscate the future," said reformist politician Mohamed ElBaradei.
Paragraph-23 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The Muslim Brotherhood´s Freedom and Justice Party played down the liberals´ criticism and walkout from parliament.
Paragraph-24 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
"The withdrawal of some members does not represent a general theme," Brotherhood leader Farid Ismail told reporters outside the meeting hall. Katatni said 85 percent of eligible members of parliament took part in the process of choosing the assembly.
Paragraph-25 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Another former presidential candidate Hamdeen Sabahy also rejected the new panel´s make-up. "The way the assembly was formed by indicates a continuation of the tendency to seek domination (by one group) and exclusion of others," Sabahy said.
Paragraph-26 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
"The revolutionary powers will not let one party exclusively write the constitution," he said.
Paragraph-27 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
(Additional reporting by Dina Zayed; Editing by Edmund Blair and Kevin Liffey) (© Thomson Reuters 2012. 06/13/12)
Paragraph-28 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY
* Members login now to write a Letter to the Editor
* Not a member click here join now
Reuters News Service Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Return to Top