Computer Viruses Won’t Stop Iran (COMMENTARY MAGAZINE) Jonathan S. Tobin 05/29/12)
Source: http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2012/05/29/computer-viruses-will-not-stop-iran-flame-stuxnet-yaalon/
Commentary Magazine
Commentary Magazine Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Iran’s confirmation that the computers of a number of their officials
have been attacked by a new virus will give further ammunition to
those who argue that the nuclear threat from the Islamist regime can
be neutered by intelligence coups and technology. Like the Stuxnet
virus which supposedly flummoxed Iran’s scientists last year, the new
Flame worm may cause some havoc in Tehran and the nuclear facilities
scattered around the country. And it will give Western and Israeli
intelligence agencies and government officials a chance to crow about
their capabilities, much as Israel’s Deputy Prime Minister Moshe
Ya’alon did today.
But even if this is Israel’s handiwork and the damage it does is
greater than then the mere temporary inconvenience wrought by
Stuxnet, no one should be fooled into thinking a virus will
ultimately stop Iran’s nuclear program if the regime is determined to
persist in its goal. Any technological attack will spawn a defense
and a counter-attack. Though Flame may give Israel and/or the West a
temporary advantage in the cyber war being conducted with Iran, it
cannot by itself or even in combination with other covert activities
such as assassinations, solve the problem. That is only possible by
diplomacy or force.
Israel’s public skepticism about the P5+1 talks being conducted by
the West with Iran about its nuclear ambitions is well-founded. Even
though the United States and its European, Russian and Chinese allies
deserve credit for not folding completely during the second round of
talks last week in Baghdad, the Iranians continue to refine uranium
and to get closer to a stockpile that could create a bomb. Iran has
every expectation that if it hangs tough, either President Obama or
the European Union will crack sometime this summer and abandon plans
for an oil embargo in exchange for an inadequate deal that would
preserve Tehran’s nuclear program.
Unlike the West’s faltering diplomacy, a course of action that
accomplishes nothing except to prevent Israel from attacking Iran, it
must be conceded that computer viruses at least have the virtue of
slowing the regime’s nuclear progress, though how much, we don’t
know. But we do know that for all of the hoopla about Stuxnet, such
delays were temporary and strategically insignificant. We can hope
for better from Flame, but the odds are it will be just a pinprick,
not a decisive stroke. As much as such schemes allow us hope for a
solution short of armed conflict, unless a miracle happens and
diplomacy succeeds, sooner or later the West and Israel will be faced
with a choice between force and living with a nuclear Iran. Like
Stuxnet, Flame may put off that day, but it cannot prevent it from
happening.
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY