Members Login
New Members Sign-Up
Top Boards
1)
Israel hails US call...
2)
Egypt admits wounded...
3)
Obama´s opportu...
4)
Palestinians fire ro...
5)
Israel, Palestinians...
6)
Israel not honoring ...
7)
Gaza Smugglers Ready...
8)
Saudi Asks Israel to...
9)
Israel’s Political S...
10)
Mideast peace takes ...
Home
>
Israel-News Today
>
This Week Must Reads
>
Quotes of the Week
Egypt vote: The Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty (BBC) British Broadcasting Company) By Kevin Connolly BBC News, Cairo 21 May 2012 Last updated at 14:03 GMT)
Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-18142902
The Headline Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
* Members login now to write a Letter to the Editor
* Choose from 1 of the 4 descriptions for the headline and or any paragraph.
* Not a member click here join now
Very few elections anywhere in the world are won and lost on foreign policy issues.
Paragraph-1 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Just ask the first President Bush who enjoyed an 88% approval rating after his victory in the first Gulf War. He went on to lose the 1992 presidential race to Bill Clinton, who ran on the slogan: "It´s the Economy Stupid."
Paragraph-2 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Egypt´s presidential poll will be no exception to that global rule.
Paragraph-3 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Whoever emerges from a crowded and unpredictable field to win will face one of the fullest in-trays in world politics.
Paragraph-4 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The very powers of the office itself will have to be defined as a new constitution is written and some kind of legacy will have to be preserved from last year´s revolution as stability is restored.
Paragraph-5 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
And there is the vital business of persuading foreign tourists to return - not to mention school places, hospital beds, water and jobs to provide for a population that has been growing at a dizzying speed.
Paragraph-6 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Unpopular neighbour
Paragraph-7 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
But one foreign policy issue does bubble away beneath the bread and butter business of electoral politics here; what should newly- democratic Egypt do about the peace treaty with Israel signed more than 30 years ago back in the days of authoritarian military rule?
Paragraph-8 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
It is a campaign issue, although it has not dominated campaigning.
Paragraph-9 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The truth is that the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel was a deal between leaderships, not a deal between peoples, and it is now deeply unpopular with the Egyptian street.
Paragraph-10 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The Egyptian military has supported the deal because it opened the way for American subsidies and access to American tanks, weapons and helicopter gunships. And there are lines of communication between Egyptian intelligence officials and their Israeli counterparts.
Paragraph-11 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Now that Egypt is becoming a democracy though, it seems inevitable that some of the popular hostility felt towards Israel will filter through into policy - or at the very least into the tone with which the Egyptian ministers deal with their Israeli counterparts.
Paragraph-12 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The general drift of events since the revolution has not been encouraging.
Paragraph-13 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
A long-standing deal under which Israel was supplied with Egyptian natural gas appears to be dead. Officially that is the result of a commercial dispute but it is bound to have a chilling effect on the diplomatic atmosphere too.
Paragraph-14 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
And more seriously, the Israeli embassy in Cairo was ransacked by an angry mob last September. Israel is not thought to have used the building since, although diplomatic relations do continue.
Paragraph-15 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Not surprisingly then, none of the candidates for the presidency has taken the view that the peace deal is to be defended or celebrated.
Paragraph-16 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The only television debate of the campaign so far brought together the two men seen at the time as front-runners; the Islamist Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, who is standing as an independent, and Amr Moussa, the former foreign minister who was once sidelined by Hosni Mubarak - apparently for the crime of becoming too popular.
Paragraph-17 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
They disagreed over whether Israel should be characterised as an "enemy" or an "adversary" - a worrying straw in the wind for the Israeli government, which on paper at least could be considered an ally.
Paragraph-18 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Mr Moussa, who has by the far the most foreign policy experience of any candidate, has signalled at the very least that the Israeli government can expect a much tougher time diplomatically if he wins.
Paragraph-19 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
He once said: "The message to Israel is clear: an entry permit to the region includes foregoing the policy of intransigence, threat, settlements and occupation and establishing a sovereign Palestinian state."
Paragraph-20 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Mr Moussa has a more informal credential in this area too. His name once featured extensively in a pop song called "I Hate Israel (But I Love Amr Moussa)". A rewritten version is out to mark the campaign.
Paragraph-21 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
But the whole issue may work best for Ahmed Shafiq, the former general who is in effect running as a kind of representative of the old days - he was the last man to be appointed prime minister by Hosni Mubarak before the old regime was swept away.
Paragraph-22 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
He is able to point to his record as a wartime fighter pilot to claim that he once shot down two Israeli military planes; that seems to imply that he is in tune with the people´s attitudes without spelling out how he would handle the relationship in any detail.
Paragraph-23 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Reviewing the relationship
Paragraph-24 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
The easiest formula for the candidates to trot out is that they favour honouring Egypt´s historic commitments but that they also favour reviewing or revising the treaty.
Paragraph-25 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
That, of course, could mean anything from tweaking the strictly- controlled troop levels on the Sinai peninsula to reconsidering the fundamental basis of the deal.
Paragraph-26 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
When I travelled to Luxor I was struck by the way in which even junior members of the various parties - including the Muslim Brotherhood´s Freedom and Justice Party and the Salafist al-Nour - trotted out that line.
Paragraph-27 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
When I asked a young Salafist if he could imagine another war with Israel in the future, he answered not that war would be terrible or unimaginable, but that Egypt could not afford a war with anyone.
Paragraph-28 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Israel watches all this anxiously, but impotently.
Paragraph-29 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
For more than 30 years, the peace treaty meant it could indulge in the luxury of reduced military vigilance on its southern border. It also paved for the way for cuts in defence spending which were a huge benefit to the civilian economy.
Paragraph-30 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
There could be no surer kiss of death in Egyptian politics than the impression a candidacy enjoyed even the tacit backing of Israel, but for all the difficulties that may lie ahead one former Israeli ambassador to Cairo, Zvi Mazel, is in no doubt that in broad historical terms the rise of democratic government in Egypt is in Israel´s interests too.
Paragraph-31 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
He told me: "We believe in our deep souls that democracy is better for Israel. A real democracy has no interest in making war... Real democracies think about the well-being of their citizens."
Paragraph-32 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
Egyptians will remember this campaign for the joy of being able to choose their own leader - and they will measure its outcome by how quickly stability returns and prosperity flourishes.
Paragraph-33 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
But sooner or later the question of the future relationship with Israel must be dealt with - and around the Middle East, and further afield in Washington, that process will be followed anxiously. (© BBC MMXII 05/21/12)
Paragraph-34 Contains
NO PROBLEM
Bias Partiality
Inaccuracies
BOTH
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY
* Members login now to write a Letter to the Editor
* Not a member click here join now
BBC} BRITISH BROADCASTING COMPANY Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Return to Top