Egypt´s election to decide army´s political future (AP) Associated Press) By HAMZA HENDAWI CAIRO, EGYPT 05/21/12 6:13 pm ET)
AP} ASSOCIATED PRESS
AP} ASSOCIATED PRESS Articles-Index-Top
CAIRO – This week´s landmark presidential election should end six
decades of effective military rule in Egypt, but it remains unclear
how much authority the generals who took over from Hosni Mubarak will
cede to the elected leader.
One thing is certain, though: the generals want no interference with
their budget, their economic empire or promotions.
The main question is whether a military that has grown accustomed to
virtually unchallenged domination over the past six decades will be
willing to quietly give it all up, or know how to deal with a
civilian president if one is elected.
"It will take years before the military and civilians learn how to
work together," said Michael W. Hanna, an Egypt expert from the
Century Foundation in New York. "The generals don´t want to rule, but
they have a dim view of civilians. And there are things they are
unlikely to budge on — things they want to have a say in, like
All of Egypt´s four presidents since the overthrow of the monarchy in
a 1952 coup have come from the military. The nation´s most powerful
institution, the military has over the years built a seemingly
unshakable image as a bastion of patriotism and the defender of the
Retired generals have consistently been given top government jobs as
Cabinet ministers, ambassadors, provincial governors, chairmen of key
state-owned firms or key posts in the private sector. Combined with
the powers of the president, a loyal police force and a coterie of
very wealthy businessmen, they have held a stranglehold on Egypt.
High on the list of their worries is whether the armed forces´ budget
will be subjected to public debate in the legislature, currently
dominated by Islamists, most of whom are at sharp odds with the
There is also the question of whether the military´s vast economic
interests — giant construction companies, farms, water-bottling
facilities and a nationwide chain of gas stations — would come under
civilian oversight or be forced to compete for lucrative government
contracts like everyone else.
Already, a member of the ruling military council has sternly warned
that anyone who tries to touch the military´s economic interests
would be harshly dealt with.
One more source of concern is whether the next president would have
the authority to pension off top brass after they reach the
retirement age of 60. Many members of the ruling military council are
well into their 60s or 70s.
None of these problems publicly surfaced under Mubarak, a career air
force officer who allowed the military to freely pursue economic
interests and accepted counsel from his defense minister on army
promotions and retirement in return for the generals´ support
throughout his 29-year rule.
Confining the military´s role to the defense of the nation has been a
main demand by the pro-democracy groups who engineered the anti-
Mubarak uprising and later called for the military to step down. Some
want the generals to be put on trial to answer for alleged crimes
during their rule, including the killing of peaceful protesters,
torturing detainees and putting civilians on trial before military
tribunals, including icon figures from the protest movement.
"Free and fair elections and the installation of a civilian president
would be a step in the right direction," said Samer S. Shehata, an
Egypt expert from Georgetown University. "It will be the first step
in the retreat, or hopefully the removal, of the military from
Mubarak, the generals´ mentor, is on trial for his life on charges of
complicity in the killing of nearly 900 protesters during the
uprising, as well as corruption. The 84-year-old former president is
to be sentenced on June 2.
Perhaps with Mubarak´s ordeal in mind, the military recently won
protection for all personnel, whether retired or in active service,
from being put on trial in civilian courts.
Publicly, the generals say they have no wish to remain in politics
and would step down immediately if they could. Any talk of wanting to
hold on to power is baseless, they say.
They have not shied away from singing their own praises, but their
infrequent public appearances have meant they had to rely on a
powerful state media, as well as influential journalists and several
loyal private television stations to promote them as the nation´s
"The military and bureaucracy are the pillars of the state of Egypt,"
commentator Gamal Abolhassan wrote in Sunday´s online edition of the
independent al-Shorouk daily. "Without them, Egypt would have
certainly slid into complete chaos."
But it was under the military´s watch, say critics, that Egypt has
seen a surge in crime, the loss of half the country´s foreign
reserves as the economy faltered and the kind of disasters thought
unimaginable just a little more than a year ago_ including the deaths
in February of more than 70 soccer fans in a riot as police stood by
The 13 candidates contesting the Wednesday-Thursday election include
Islamists, liberals and two with military backgrounds, among them a
retired air force commander who was Mubarak´s last prime minister.
No outright winner is expected to emerge from the two-day vote, so a
runoff is scheduled for June 16-17 between the two top finishers.
The election is the last stop in a turbulent transitional period
before the generals hand back power by July 1 as they promised soon
after Mubarak´s ouster in last year´s 18-day popular uprising.
Media leaks over the past week of an impending "constitutional
declaration" sponsored by the military to give it vast powers and
defining those of the next president have sparked fears the generals
are trying to create "a state within the state."
The leaks prompted party leaders to enter emergency negotiations to
try to come up with a constitutional declaration of their own.
Meanwhile, the military has remained publicly silent on the issue.
Despite the controversy, the race´s front-runners have apparently
decided not to heighten tension with the military, at least for now.
Rights lawyer Khaled Ali was the only candidate to address the issue
at a news conference called Monday to voice fears over any such
constitutional declaration which, if issued, would serve as an
interim charter pending the drafting of a permanent constitution.
The military, meanwhile, sought on Monday to head off any post-
election unrest, reassuring Egyptians that it has no favorite in the
race and that voters will decide the next president.
"It is important that we all accept the election results, which will
reflect the free choice of the Egyptian people, bearing in mind that
Egypt´s democratic process is taking its first step and we all must
contribute to its success," the ruling military council said in a
There has been widespread speculation that the military favors Ahmed
Shafiq, the former air force commander who served as Mubarak´s civil
aviation minister for 10 years before he named him prime minister in
his final days in power.
A front-runner whose support has significantly risen in opinion polls
in recent days, Shafiq´s name is tainted by his links to Mubarak.
Islamists have threatened massive protests if he is elected and
contend that he could only win if the vote was rigged. (© 2012 The
Associated Press 05/21/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY