Robert Fulford: Israel is a nation of survivors (NATIONAL POST COMMENT) Robert Fulford 05/19/12)
Source: http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2012/05/19/robert-fulford-israel-is-a-nation-of-survivors/
NATIONAL POST
NATIONAL POST Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
A nation of survivors and the descendants of survivors, Israel has
now survived for 64 difficult years. By this point it would seem to
have staked a reasonable claim on the affections of all nations that
share its beliefs in honest elections, independent judges and freedom
of speech and commerce. But in the community of democratic states
Israel is more often regarded with suspicion. Unwarranted hostility
is one of the forces it routinely faces while pursuing survival.
Its sworn enemies are routinely treated with more sympathy. The
universities of North America have become comfortable homes for a pro-
Palestinian movement that is genially tolerated despite its
outrageous rhetoric and mobster tactics. The world’s leftists, once
admirers of Israel’s progressive social experiments, have become
implacable enemies. The UN is so profoundly prejudiced against Israel
that most people, inside and outside Israel, no longer notice its
behaviour; those who believe UN reports must also believe Israel
commits more crimes against human rights than all other nations
combined.
Most democratic governments believe they know precisely how Israel
should solve its problems. They do not hesitate to pass their
opinions along to Jerusalem, often in the form of demands. It appears
that Israel fails to live up to the moral standards of Britain,
France and other countries. In fact, the only nation that habitually
gives Israel the benefit of the doubt, rather than the benefit of
harsh advice, is Canada. Patriotic Israelis must feel on some days
that nearly every foreign voice speaks out against them.
How can this be? Israel’s history is difficult and complicated. The
world finds it hard to understand.
When Roman power obliterated Jerusalem in the year 70, Jews were left
stateless and defenceless. Some remained in Palestine. Others somehow
maintained their religion and identity in whatever new homes they
found. But they lived as outsiders who could be displaced whenever
their host countries wanted them gone. In the late 19th century the
Zionist movement began to plan for a permanent home, centred on
Jerusalem; in 1909 the first new Jewish town was created, Tel Aviv.
In the 1940s, Hitler, by killing 6 million Jews, turned the dream of
a secure homeland into a matter of urgent necessity.
The British, governors of Palestine under an international mandate,
had promised that Jewish and Arab states would share the territory.
In 1947 the UN approved a two-state partition, which the Jews
accepted but the Arabs did not. On May 14, 1948, Israel declared
independence. Immediately the armies of Egypt, Syria, Transjordan,
Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Iraq invaded. The secretary-general of the
Arab League, Abdul Rahman Hassan Azzam, had predicted this would be a
massacre, “a war of elimination.” But Israel soon turned back the
invaders and secured its territory (though not all of the city of
Jerusalem).
In May, 1967, the Arab states again decided they could not tolerate
Israel’s existence. They gathered their armies and moved toward its
borders. “The Arab people want to fight,” said president Gamal Abdel
Nasser of Egypt, the most powerful Arab of the day. “Our basic
objective will be the destruction of Israel.” Egypt, Jordan and Syria
had help from Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and Algeria. Israel
was outnumbered about two to one in troops, three to one in tanks and
combat aircraft. Israel struck first and won. The Six-Day War ended
on June 10 with the land controlled by Israel having expanded about
100%.
This, including the West Bank of the Jordan River, is now called
occupied territory. The Arab states whose aggressive misjudgment and
incompetence caused this region to fall into Israeli hands now blame
Israel for the sin of acquiring it; in fact the world “colonial” is
often used, as if Israel had set out on a war of conquest, like
Britain or France in the past. Israel has tried to trade back this
territory in various land-for-peace schemes, to no avail.
Iran is now a persistent threat, the Hamas rockets from Gaza are
seldom silent and the gathering strength of the Muslim Brotherhood,
just across the border in Egypt, is ominous. Israel could use the
moral support of the other democracies. Hillel Harkin, a
distinguished American-born Israeli author, has suggested how high
the stakes are: “Zionism is the belief that the Jews should have a
state. To defame Israel is to defame the Jews. To wish that it never
existed is to wish to destroy the Jews.” A harsh truth, and not a
truth the world is eager to embrace. (© 2012 National Post, a
division of Postmedia Network Inc. 05/19/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY