Palestinians Short of Ideas, Not Guns (COMMENTARY MAGAZINE) Jonathan S. Tobin 05/14/12)
Source: http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2012/05/13/palestinians-short-of-ideas-not-guns-abbas-peace-netanyahu-obama/
Commentary Magazine
Commentary Magazine Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas is complaining that Israel
is making it difficult for his security forces to obtain weapons. As
the New York Times reports, Abbas claimed yesterday in a meeting with
members of the left-wing J Street group that the problems his police
have been encountering recently is due to their difficulty importing
arms. He also dismissed the letter Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu sent him imploring the Palestinian to return to direct
peace talks without preconditions.
However, the claim that any holdup in arms shipments is making it
impossible for the PA to fulfill its commitments to keep the peace is
absurd. As a senior Israeli source told the Times, there is no
shortage of guns or ammunition in the West Bank. The various PA
security forces are all armed to the teeth. The material Abbas wants
to import from Russia and Egypt is not police equipment but armaments
that would transform the PA’s forces into the sort of army the Oslo
peace accords specifically forbid. Moreover, because the PA is making
an alliance with the radical Islamists of Hamas rather than fighting
them, what possible purpose would Abbas have for heavy weapons?
Abbas has a sympathetic audience in J Street. It has supported his
effort to evade blame for refusing to talk peace in order to justify
its opposition to Israel’s government. Such a stance treats the
Palestinians as being without any responsibility for their actions.
The PA has long tried to claim it was powerless, but this latest
rejection of peace talks demonstrates anew that what they are short
of is ideas, not guns.
The PA leader is still under the mistaken impression that he needn’t
talk to Prime Minister Netanyahu. He believes President Obama, left-
wing Jews like J Street and an international community deeply hostile
to the Jewish state will eventually bludgeon Israel into granting his
demands that it surrender on every point of contention before
negotiations even begin. But as his failed attempt to get the United
Nations to recognize Palestinian independence — the
diplomatic “tsunami” that was supposed to overwhelm Israel but
instead merely demonstrated that the world had little interest in the
Palestinians — without the PA first making peace with Israel should
have taught him this strategy is not going to work. Nor should he
hold his breath waiting for President Obama to risk the ire of
Americans voters by picking another fight with Israel this year.
It is unfortunate that groups like J Street feed into his delusions
about the world’s interest in forcing Israel into granting his
desires. Abbas may harbor hopes a re-elected Obama will return to the
pattern of his first three years in office and again seek to pressure
Netanyahu to give in to Palestinian demands. But even if that comes
to pass, there is only so much his foreign friends can do for him if
he isn’t willing to talk to the Israelis. Abbas has demonstrated time
and again that he isn’t willing or capable of signing a peace
agreement that would recognize the legitimacy of a Jewish state no
matter where its borders are drawn.
Rather than whining to groups that aren’t willing to hold him
responsible for his inability to import Russia munitions, what Abbas
needs to do is to signal his willingness to make peace on realistic
terms. Until that happens, neither Netanyahu — who enjoys the support
of the vast majority of Israelis — or even a re-elected Obama are
going to pay much attention to his complaints.
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY