Fayyad Acknowledges Palestinians Are “Losing the Argument” (COMMENTARY MAGAZINE) Seth Mandel 05/09/12)
Source: http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2012/05/09/fayyadpalestinians-losing-the-argument/
Commentary Magazine
Commentary Magazine Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
While it’s true the Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an
opportunity, their “friends” don’t do them any favors either. From
the conspiracy theorists ranting about the “Israel Lobby” to “peace
studies” intellectuals who inevitably turn out to be vicious anti-
Semites to the proudly ignorant activists who debase the Civil Rights
movement and the struggle against South African apartheid by using
those terms in vain, pro-Palestinian advocates have been manifestly
unable to mount a serious intellectual argument for their cause. And
failed Prime Minister Salam Fayyad seems to know it.
Reuters interviewed the hapless technocrat, and he couched his
failure in terms more sensible than his allies ever offer:
Prime Minister Salam Fayyad said on Tuesday the Palestinians may
have “lost the argument” on the international stage for an
independent state but cautioned that continued Israeli occupation was
unsustainable….
He also warned his administration’s future was clouded by severe
financial strains and said the Palestinians had failed to galvanize a
distracted world behind their cause.
“I think we are losing the argument, if we have not already lost the
argument. But that doesn’t make our position wrong,” said the former
World Bank economist, a political independent who has had strong
support amongst Western powers.
Yes, they are losing the argument, and have been for quite some time.
Statehood in the real world is not something you’re granted for
pitching a fit and kicking dirt at the United Nations. The toxic mix
of cowards and criminals who make up the “flotilla” movement won’t
convince anyone you’re ready to be treated like a responsible actor
on the world stage. And brainwashing young minds to hate your “peace
partners” isn’t the strongest case for independence.
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency, which exists to keep poor
Palestinians penned up in refugee camps to radicalize instead of
educate them, has contributed its own acid to the steady corrosion of
the prospects for a peaceful settlement. And never permitting, let
alone encouraging, a sense of moral responsibility on the part of the
Palestinians is the opposite of being pro-Palestinian–it shows, as
Bret Stephens pointed out in his review of Peter Beinart’s new
book, “an unwitting, but profound, contempt” for the Palestinians by
assigning them “no moral agency.”
Fayyad seems to understand that a myopic focus on Israel keeps people
talking about Israel. But it would behoove the Palestinians and their
defenders to talk a bit about the Palestinians and their cause. Is
there a case for Palestinian statehood? I’m sure there is, but Fayyad
may now understand that the global left cannot be relied upon to make
it.
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY