Coalition to pass Kadima’s alternative to Tal Law (JERUSALEM POST) By LAHAV HARKOV, JEREMY SHARON 05/09/12)
JERUSALEM POST Articles-Index-Top
The “Tal Law” will be replaced with a Kadima-led, government-
sponsored Basic Law requiring all citizens to perform military or
civilian service, with changes suggested by the Likud, following the
new coalition agreement signed on Tuesday.
According to the agreement, both sides will work to pass a law to
ensure “equal and fair distribution of the burden of IDF service
between the parts of Israel’s population” by July 31, 2012, the date
the Tal Law will no longer be valid, according to the High Court.
In addition, the agreement says a staff headed by Kadima will compose
Two weeks ago, MK Yohanan Plesner, who chaired a Knesset Foreign
Affairs and Defense Subcommittee on the Tal Law, presented Kadima’s
alternative bill, which will implement mandatory service for all
within five years. All citizens will be recruited to serve either in
the IDF or in areas of domestic security, education, welfare, health,
emergency services and immigrant absorption. Anyone who does not
serve if called will be denied any payments from the government.
In addition, 1,000 exemplary yeshiva students will be exempt from
service, and other yeshiva students may defer serving in the military
or national service for one year, every year for a maximum of eight
Likud sources said the party will suggest changes to the bill, so
that it can pass without haredi parties leaving the coalition.
The main change is expected to be the reverse of allowing an
exemption for 1,000 yeshiva students. Rather than limiting the number
of students, the legislation is likely to present a minimum number of
haredim doing military or national service, which will be increased
This gradual increase will allow both the IDF and haredi society to
prepare for the major changes this legislation is likely to bring.
While Kadima leader Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Kadima
leader Shaul Mofaz expressed confidence that the new policy will be
passed, several Kadima MKs told The Jerusalem Post they are skeptical
about its chances, citing distrust of Netanyahu, among other reasons.
The Haredi Knesset factions have greeted the new coalition
arrangements cautiously, but United Torah Judaism leaders said that
their party would remain in the coalition for the mean time and said
that they welcomed efforts to strengthen the government.
However, Deputy Health Minister Yaakov Litzman (United Torah Judaism)
emphasized that, as the party sees it, the original coalition
agreement made when the government was first formed in 2009 still
stands, and the addition of Kadima does change the original coalition
He pointed out that in particular, the principle of military service
deferrals for haredi men learning in yeshiva, Torato Omunato, was a
central part of the coalition agreement.
“There can’t be a situation in Israel in 2012 where someone who wants
to study Torah will not be able to do so,” Litzman said. “But as long
as the principle of Torato Omunato is preserved UTJ will remain in
He added that the idea of capping the number of yeshiva students
eligible for military service exemptions would be unacceptable, but
conceded however that “anyone who is not learning as he should be
should be drafted.”
Nevertheless, the Deputy Minister admitted that the party was
concerned about the proposals for a Tal Law replacement made before
the new coalition deal was announced.
A spokesman for UTJ MK and Finance Committee chair Moshe Gafni said
that how the issue is managed is now in the hands of the Prime
Minister, but that the party hopes that any new law will be worked
out on the basis of compromise and agreement.
As to the idea of setting a quota for the number of haredim who must
be drafted every year, Shas MK Nissim Ze’ev told the Post that, in
his opinion, this policy is already in place de-facto and has been
since 2008, possibly referring to government goals for haredi
enlistment set following the renewal of the Tal Law in 2008.
He said however, that Shas insists that the principle of Torato
Omunato remains in place, and did not see any contradiction between
this policy and the idea of setting a quota for drafting a set number
of men from the haredi sector every year.
He added that he was extremely pleased the Knesset would not be
dissolved because it would prevent radicalization within Kadima
regarding the Tal Law, and would also prevent Yair Lapid from
influencing the issue with his “extremist” policies.
“Now that there’s more time to discuss the issue, we can talk about
it with more respect and in greater sincerity, not just in populist
terms,” Ze’ev said,
“But the prime minister must try to bridge between the demands of the
different sectors. The only way to achieve anything on this issue is
He added that there were many different solutions and alternatives
for getting the ultra-Orthodox community to take up the “yoke of
serving the state,” a process which he said is already underway.
Boaz Nol, one of the leaders of the “Camp Sucker” IDF draft-reform
movement, called the developments a “potential revolution” and said
that his movement welcomed the new coalition arrangements, provided
that they result in a new law mandating obligatory military or
civilian service for all.
“A few months ago, it seemed like the Tal Law was simply going to be
extended for another five years, but following our efforts, this
issue has spurred the formation of what is basically a new
government, so we’re proud and happy about these developments,” said
“But the faith of the electorate in the Prime Minister and Shaul
Mofaz, and their personal integrity, is now on the altar, so we need
to see results in three months’ time,” he added. (© 1995-2011, The
Jerusalem Post 05/09/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY