There is no such thing as a two-state solution (JERUSALEM POST OP-ED) By JOE WALSH 05/07/12)
Source: http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Op-EdContributors/Article.aspx?id=268934
JERUSALEM POST
JERUSALEM POST Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
It has been 64 years since the United Nations General Assembly
approved the Partition Plan for Palestine and the struggle to
implement a “two-state solution” began. Today we are no closer to
that end.
It reminds me of that definition of insanity: doing the same thing
over and over again and expecting different results. By that
definition, everyone who continues to cling to the delusion of a two-
state solution is insane. There is no such thing as a two-state
solution. It cannot work, it has not worked, and it will not work.
The only viable solution for the Middle East is a one-state solution:
one, contiguous Israeli state from the Jordan River to the
Mediterranean Sea. There will not and cannot be lasting peace in the
Middle East until then.
Ever since the Palestinians and Arab countries refused to accept the
Mandate for Palestine, the original two-state solution, the
international community has been catering to Palestinian and Arab
demands for a divided Israel. The Palestinians and Arabs, however,
have repeatedly rejected these proposals, including the 1947 United
Nations Partition Plan for Palestine, which they now are using to
justify their demands for a divided Israel. Enough is enough.
Why is the international community continuing to kowtow to these
demands, when for 64 years the Palestinians and the Arabs have
actively worked against peace? Israel is the only country in the
region that has shown that it wants and will work toward peace. Since
1947, the Palestinian and Arab countries have fought more than five
wars against Israel over territory, and each opportunity a victorious
Israel returned land it acquired in exchange for peace.
The Palestinians have broken their word again and again. They
continue to intentionally fire rockets at innocent Israeli families
and children, and they have betrayed the fundamental tenet of the two-
state solution they tout by cutting Israel out of negotiations and
going directly to the United Nations.
Moreover, the Palestinian Authority continues to incite violence
against Israelis. It pays the salaries of imprisoned terrorists
convicted of killing Israelis and glorifies suicide bombers at public
events. The PA’s magazine Zayzafuna recently presented Hitler as a
role model for the Palestinian youth on account of all the Jews he
had killed.
Most importantly, how can a people divided between radically
different and violently opposed factions possibly govern a single
state overnight? Right now, the Palestinians are divided between
Hamas in the Gaza Strip and Fatah in the West Bank. These factions
fought a civil war no more than 5 years ago and are fundamentally
irreconcilable. Who will then govern a unified Palestinian state?
The two-state solution can never work when one of those states, the
Palestinian state, does not even acknowledge the other state’s
(Israel´s) very right to exist and has as its entire purpose to wipe
Israel off the face of the earth. Never will peace come when one side
possesses such hate and routinely expresses that hate through
violence and blood.
It is time to let go of the two-state solution insanity and adopt the
only solution that will bring true peace to the Middle East – a
single Israeli state from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea.
Israel is the only country in the region dedicated to peace and the
only power capable of stable, just and democratic government in the
region.
This solution is the best one for everyone, especially the
Palestinians. They will trade their two corrupt and inept governments
and societies for a stable, free and prosperous one. Those
Palestinians that wish to may leave their Fatah and Hamas-created
slums and move to the original Palestinian state – Jordan. The
British Mandate for Palestine created Jordan as the country for the
Palestinians. It was the only justification for its creation. Even
now, 75 percent of its population is of Palestinian descent. Those
Palestinians that remain behind in Israel will maintain limited
voting power, but will be awarded all the economic and civil rights
of Israeli citizens. They will be free to raise a family, start a
business and live in peace, all of which are impossible under Arab
rule.
The two-state solution has failed. Only a one state solution – a
single, undivided Israel – will bring peace, security, and prosperity
to Israelis and Palestinians alike. It’s time for the United States
to lead on this. For over 60 years, peace has been the goal, common
sense and basic human morality have been ignored, and peace has not
come. We’ve had it backwards all these years: the goal should not be
peace at all costs. The goal should be a strong, free and prosperous
Israel. The United States should not be some honest broker between
two sides but rather publicly stand with one side – Israel. Then, and
only then, will real peace truly come.
The writer is a US congressman from Illinois and a member of the
Congressional Israel Allies Caucus. (© 1995-2011, The Jerusalem Post
05/07/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY