Robert Fulford: They’re blaming Israel again, what a surprise (NATIONAL POST COMMENT) 04/28/12)
Source: http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2012/04/28/robert-fulford-theyre-blaming-israel-again-what-a-surprise/
NATIONAL POST
NATIONAL POST Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Across the Middle East this year, Christians are in more trouble than
at any previous point in memory. Massacres and beatings by Islamist
mobs have caused 200,000 Copts to leave Egypt, their home for 16
centuries. In Iraq, scores of churches have been burned and many
worshippers killed. The Christian population in most Arab states is
sharply declining.
So last Sunday, the producers of the CBS show 60 Minutes did an item
exposing the problems that afflict Christians … in Israel.
It was a colossal case of missing the point. Israel is the only state
in the Middle East where Christians are guaranteed religious freedom,
and the only place where they serve in parliament and on the Supreme
Court.
But Bob Simon and the 60 Minutes crew found a fresh reason to
complain about Israel’s treatment of a minority. Apparently, many
Christian Arabs are leaving Jerusalem and the West Bank city of
Jerusalem because they no longer find it comfortable to live there.
This could leave churches without congregations. Stripped of its
Christians, Simon predicted, the major Christian sites could turn
into mere tourist attractions, scattered Christian theme parks.
He reported that Arab Christians feel hemmed in by the security wall
that Israel built to keep Palestinian suicide terrorists from
slipping into Israel. Understandably, the Christian Arabs also find
it maddening to deal with endless delays at the checkpoints, built
for the same reason. They don’t give their views of the terrorists
who made these burdens necessary, but they’re not pleased with
Israel’s (so far successful) system of defence.
The 60 Minutes footage showed one family living in the shadow of the
security wall, each of its windows facing a guard tower or blank
vistas of cement. That’s the kind of thing that’s driving the
Christians out, Simon explained. Weirdly, however, the item did not
show us a single Christian Arab who actually had left for this
reason — or for any other reason.
Did some, perhaps, leave because of pressure from rising Islamist
power, Hamas and its adherents? Not one, so far as 60 Minutes knows.
The producer brought on a Christian Arab businessman, the guy who
holds the Coke franchise for the West Bank, who said he had never,
ever heard of any Christian who had been bothered by Muslim
harassment. Apparently, this is the one place in the entire region
where Christians and Muslims live in utter peace.
Michael Oren, the Israeli ambassador to Washington, appeared on the
program as a whipping boy for Simon. No one mentioned that he’s a
distinguished historian and journalist, a visiting professor at
Harvard and Yale and the author of the definitive history of the 1967
war. Simon did say Oren had been Israel’s former director of inter-
religious affairs. Otherwise, he could have been any foreign ministry
bureaucrat.
He was included in the show, we soon learned, in order to be scolded.
Some months ago, Oren heard that 60 Minutes was planning a hatchet
job on Israel’s treatment of Palestinian Christians. Oren got in
touch with the head of CBS News and suggested this should be
reconsidered.
As a public-relations move, that was not necessarily shrewd. But
Simon made such a fuss about it that he clearly wanted the audience
to see it as a terrible, terrible infraction of the rules — and
unprecedented. In his vast experience as a broadcaster, Simon
claimed, no public official had ever before complained to management
about an item that hadn’t yet been broadcast.
It was clearly a most serious offence against the gods of journalism.
It was a “You went over my head! You called my boss!” crime, the kind
of thing that makes self-important TV stars jump onto high horses in
their eagerness to prove they are more important and have more
inalienable rights than anyone they write or talk about. Journalists
hate it when their own bosses are called, but never hesitate to use
the same strategy when roles are reversed.
Why in the world, Simon wanted to know, would Israel express concern
about an item that hadn’t yet been aired? By Simon’s account, no one,
not even he, could guess the final shape of the story, even when the
interview with Oren was being recorded.
Surely the Israeli government couldn’t imagine that CBS journalists
would know the slant of a story even before the reporting and editing
were done?
Perhaps Michael Oren, being a historian, remembered a few things in
the past, such as the last 15 or 20 stories about Israel that 60
Minutes had produced.
And as it turned out, his experience-based prediction was precisely
accurate. (© 2012 National Post, a division of Postmedia Network Inc.
04/28/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY