Taliban talks terrify Afghan women / New rights in fragile state (WASHINGTON TIMES) By Ashish Kumar Sen 04/18/12)
WASHINGTON TIMES Articles-Index-Top
A real war on women is brewing in Afghanistan.
Women there are worried that the freedoms they have won since U.S.
forces toppled the brutal Taliban regime 10 years ago will be
squandered if the Islamic hard-liners return to power through a U.S.-
led peace process.
“Dark days are in Afghanistan’s future,” said Manizha Naderi, who
heads the civil rights group Women for Afghan Women.
U.S. and Afghan officials and the Taliban have been engaged for
several months in an effort to initiate peace talks that could lead
to the militants playing a role in government.
“If there are negotiations with the Taliban, women’s rights will be
the first to go, and women will be forced to stay at home all over
again,” Ms. Naderi said in a phone interview from Kabul.
Afghan women bore the brunt of the Taliban’s strict enforcement of
Islamic law until U.S. forces overthrew the regime for sheltering al
Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist
The Taliban regrouped as a militant force and claimed credit this
week for coordinated suicide bombings in Kabul and other cities.
Under the Taliban regime, girls were banned from going to school and
women’s educational institutions were closed. Many women were forced
to quit their jobs and required to wear burqas.
Taliban fighters perpetrated egregious acts of violence against
women, including rape, abduction and forced marriage, according to a
2001 report by the State Department.
Unmarried women who were caught with unrelated men were whipped in
stadiums full of people. Married women in similar circumstances were
stoned to death.
Now schools across Afghanistan brim with girls. Access to health care
has reduced the female mortality rate. Women play a role in politics
and public life, and the Afghan Constitution criminalizes violence
The Taliban still routinely threaten women who have taken on public
roles in society. In some instances, female politicians and social
workers have been killed.
In an attack Tuesday that officials blamed on extremists opposed to
female education, about 140 Afghan girls and teachers were poisoned
by contaminated drinking water at a high school in the northern
Takhar province. Some remained in critical condition at a hospital,
while others were treated and released.
“We all are afraid of the Taliban coming back in any shape, whether
in power in government or as an independent political party,” said
Nilofar Sakhi, chairwoman of Women’s Activities and Social Services
Association, based in Afghanistan’s western city of Herat.
The Taliban suspended peace talks with the United States last month,
setting back the Obama administration’s efforts to end the war in
Afghanistan before U.S. combat troops withdraw by the end of 2014.
The U.S. and Afghan governments have laid down three conditions for
the peace process. The Taliban must renounce al Qaeda, disarm and
respect the Afghan Constitution.
The Taliban have refused to recognize Afghan President Hamid Karzai’s
government, which they refer to as a “puppet,” and have shown no
inclination to abide by the Afghan Constitution.
“By not respecting the Afghan Constitution, the Taliban will
undermine the gains made by women,” Ms. Sakhi said.
Karzai’s commitment questioned
There is a risk that the gains made by women “can be traded off for
short-term political gain,” said Sima Samar, chairwoman of the
Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission.
Mr. Karzai’s own commitment to these freedoms is also a cause of
concern for some women.
He has signed laws that protect women’s rights but also has made
comments that have alarmed defenders of those rights.
Mr. Karzai ignited a firestorm last year when he attempted to bring
all women’s shelters in Afghanistan under government control.
“This was, in our opinion, a hint to the Taliban that when they have
a role in the government women’s rights will be on the table,” said
Esther Hyneman, a board member at Women for Afghan Women.
“Mr. Karzai abandoned the effort in the face of international
pressure, but he had made his point: to illustrate to the Taliban
that women’s rights can be disposed of.”
Last month, Mr. Karzai endorsed a statement from the country’s top
religious council that women should not interact with men in schools,
offices, universities and shopping centers.
The council also said that women should not travel without male
relatives and must respect the right of men to polygamy.
“It is Talibanism all over again, and Karzai did nothing to fight
it,” said Ms. Hyneman. “He was supportive of rules against women’s
freedom that go totally backwards.”
The Karzai administration has set up a High Peace Council to lead the
reconciliation process with the militants. Nine of the 69 council
members are women, but critics complain that the women’s presence has
been largely symbolic.
“The nine women on the peace council are not part of any negotiations
with the Taliban,” said Asila Wardak Jamal, director of Human Rights
and Women’s International Affairs in the Afghan Foreign Ministry.
The international community can safeguard hard-won rights and
freedoms by supporting the women on the council, she added.
The challenge will be to ensure that the international community
protects women’s rights in Afghanistan in any peace process.
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton assured a meeting of the
U.S.-Afghan Women’s Council in Washington last month of the U.S.
“Any peace that is attempted to be made by excluding more than half
the population is no peace at all,” she said. “It is a figment that
will not last.”
Two top reasons Afghan women are apprehensive about reconciliation
with the Taliban are a lack of transparency and inclusivity in the
“We have to push for a more meaningful role for women,” Ms. Sakhi
While some women, like Ms. Naderi, say peace cannot be achieved
through negotiations with terrorists, others, like Ms. Sakhi, say
women’s groups need to be less rigid in their stances on
What all women can agree on is that peace in Afghanistan must not
come at the cost of their newfound freedoms.
“Women would like to bring peace to this country and put an end to
this war, but will not agree to pay any price,” Ms. Jamal said.
“Nobody would like to go back to the period of the Taliban.” (© 2012
The Washington Times, LLC. 04/18/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY