Ehud Barak condemns IDF officer who beat pro-Palestinian protester (HA´ARETZ NEWS) By Haaretz 04/18/12)
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE Articles-Index-Top
On Tuesday, Defense Minister Ehud Barak condemned the Israel Defense
Forces officer who was filmed over the weekend hitting a Danish
protester with his rifle butt in the Jordan Valley.
In a statement released by his office on Tuesday night, Barak
responded to the incident for the first time . "The defense minister
has determined, in closed conversations, that there is no
contradiction between carrying out operations, appropriate behavior
and preserving the principles and spirit of the IDF," said the
The statement went on to criticize any justifications for IDF Lt.
Col. Shaul Eisner´s behavior made over the past day. "Barak said
tonight that the baseless statements made over the past 24 hours that
the severe and out of the ordinary behavior conducted by the senior
officer emerged from an operational necessity or out of a principle
of sticking to an operation, are not accepted by the defense minister
and were never acceptable by the IDF," said the statement.
The defense minister´s statement followed a personal response by the
IDF officer, earlier on Tuesday, to allegations made against him.
Eisner, who was suspended from duties following the incident, told
Channel 10 that "it could have been a professional mistake to use a
weapon in front of the cameras." The televised report also showed a
document indicating he had broken his finger.
Video footage posted on YouTube showed Eisner, deputy commander of
the IDF´s Jordan Valley brigade, striking Danish activist Andreas Ias
in the face with an M-16 rifle during a cycle rally near Jericho in
the West Bank.
"It was a two minute confrontation," he said," so yes, it´s true that
some pictures look bad, but I used a weapon… in a cold manner, as a
stick. I didn´t kill anyone and I did not put anyone´s life in
danger." He added that he believes that thanks to his actions the
protesters called off the demonstration.
Ias, the Danish activist that was hit in the face, said on Monday
that the officer´s claim that the activists were violent is a
fabrication. Also on Monday, the Danish ambassador asked Israel to
explain the officer´s assault on Ias.
"These stories do not interest the Chief of Staff or my Front
Commander," Eisner added on Tuesday. He admitted there are "a few
questions," yet maintained that he "does not accept this as a moral
failure in any way." "We know the history of these anarchists," he
said, "they came with sticks and broke my hand – but no one will tell
or film that."
"There is a question here of what is more important – to carry out
the mission or to look good (in pictures). I claim the mission is
important enough," Eisner said. He added: "What if they would film
IDF soldiers backing down from an angry crowd? That sounds good?
What, I´d let them block roads? I´d let them endanger lives?"
President Shimon Peres on Monday said he was "shocked" by the
incident, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday condemned
the incident, which was seen in a film posted on YouTube earlier
"Such behavior does not characterize IDF soldiers and officers and
has no place in the Israel Defense Forces and in the State of
Israel," Netanyahu said.
On Tuesday, a few dozen demonstrators headed by National Union MK
Michael Ben Ari gathered in front of the Kirya Defense Ministry
complex to show support for Eisner. They called on the IDF to award
him a medal for his conduct. (© Copyright 2012 Ha´aretz 04/18/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY