Who will be the next Egyptian president? (HA´ARETZ NEWS) By Avi Issacharoff 03/30/12)
Source: http://www.haaretz.com/news/features/who-will-be-the-next-egyptian-president-1.421378
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
Despite the Muslim Brotherhood´s promises not to enter a candidate in
the upcoming Egyptian presidential elections in May, the
organization´s leadership meets next week in order to discuss the
possibility. While there is no certainty that it will enter the race,
if it does the Shura Council is expected to choose between two front-
runners, Mohammed Morsi - leader of the Brotherhood´s Freedom and
Justice Party - and Mohamed Saad al-Katatni, Egypt´s Parliament
Speaker. The man thought to be the Brotherhood´s leading candidate -
movement deputy chairman Khairat el-Shater - previously announced
that he would not run.
One of the Brotherhood representatives in parliament, Mohamed Emad el-
Din, said that the movement - which yesterday opted to defer its
decision by a week until next Tuesday - might support a candidate
outside its own ranks, even though its young members are pressing the
Brotherhood to stay out of the presidential elections as promised.
The discussions in the Shura Council will be conducted against the
backdrop of unprecedented tension between the movement and Egypt´s
ruling Supreme Military Council. The "honeymoon" between the
organizations, as it was termed by an Egyptian commentator, seems to
be at an end. The military council this week accused the Islamist
movement of trying to undermine the government and of smearing the
council, following a statement by the Brotherhood that the council
was attempting to encroach upon the gains of the January 2011
revolution.
The power struggle between the ruling council and the Brotherhood is
expressed in two places where significant storms are raging: the
parliament and the presidential election, scheduled for May 23-24.
The parliament is agitated in the wake of the formation of a new
committee charged with writing a national constitution; it was set to
meet today for the first time.
The constitutional committee is to determine the president´s
authority and his relations with the legislature and the
administrative branch of government. Secular opposition, members of
the liberal parties, the left and young people have accused the
Brotherhood and the extreme Islamist Salafi party Al-Nour of gaining
control of the committee and appointing their members, in order to
prevent the creation of a consensual constitution. There are 100
members on the committee; according to the Al-Ahram newspaper, at
least 65 percent are Islamists.
The second fight is taking place around the list of candidates for
the presidency. In less than two months, Egyptians will choose their
next president in the country´s first democratic elections - the most
significant figure in Egypt according to present laws. The historical
importance of the event may explain the large number of candidates -
200 - some of whom are serious and familiar political faces, while
many others are raw material for dozens of satirical reviews, and
about whom there are doubts whether they will really run for the
position.
At the beginning of the week, one of three leading candidates,
Mansour Hassan, announced he was leaving the race. A former
information minister in the days of Anwar Sadat, Hassan was set to
become Sadat´s deputy but was prevented from doing so by the 1981
assassination; he was kept far from the center of power when Hosni
Mubarak was president. In recent weeks his name has often been
mentioned as an outstanding candidate supported by all circles -
until he was negatively dubbed the "accommodation" candidate. There
were many rumors that Hassan would be accepted by the Supreme
Military Council on the one hand, and the Muslim Brotherhood on the
other, as part of a political deal meant to preserve the power of
these two organizations. But on Sunday he left the race and put an
end to these conspiracy theories.
The Egyptian elections constitute a critical phase for the country
after Mubarak. In effect they will end the interim stage, according
to Prof. Yoram Meital, head of the Chaim Herzog Center for Middle
East Studies and Diplomacy at Ben-Gurion University. That is,
authority will be transferred from the ruling military council to an
elected body.
"We are entering [a period of] unprecedented power struggle over who
controls the reins of government," Meital says. He adds that Egypt
has several centers of power, and that one of its muddier centers is
the institution of the presidency: "The first [center of power] is
the parliament, which is controlled by the Muslim Brotherhood and the
Salafis. The second is the military council, which has managed
government business during the interim period and is to transfer its
authority to the elected leadership on July 1. My estimation is that
the military council will continue to be involved, but behind the
scenes.
"The third center is supposed to be the presidency," Meital
continues. "We don´t know who will be chosen, and when the results
are known all the cards in the political arena will be reshuffled.
The fourth center of power I call ´Tahrir Square.´ There are no more
demonstrations, but there is rage and disappointment on the part of
important sectors who initiated the January 2011 revolution and feel
they´ve been left behind without political representation. The fifth
center is the [acting] government. Now the interim government is led
by [Prime Minister] Kamal el-Ganzouri and the question arises: who
will form the next one?"
According to Meital, this question is at the heart of the
constitutional issue. "How will the president´s authority be defined
in relation to the parliament and the government? Who will assemble
the government? The majority in Egypt supports a reduction in
presidential authority and an increase in that held by the parliament
and government offices. On the other hand, against the background of
the Islamists´ achievements in the [parliamentary] elections, the
impression is that secular forces along with the military council are
not interested in weakening the presidency. This question is not only
about the nature of the presidency but about the future of the
regime."
In addition to the Muslim Brotherhood candidates (if there are any ),
leading candidates include Amr Moussa, former Egyptian foreign
minister and Arab League chief; and Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, a
former senior member of the Brotherhood who decided to run
independently and was then removed from the organization´s ranks. New
and surprising candidates are likely to be added to the race in
coming months. Candidates require the signatures of 30,000 citizens,
or 30 members of parliament, to run.
Amr Moussa garnered broad support when he entered the race and was
considered the leading candidate until a few months ago, but has lost
ground since - in part because of his past as a senior member of the
Mubarak regime. Aboul Fotouh may prove to be the biggest surprise of
these elections. He has been considered the political rival of
Brotherhood leader Mohammed Badie since his days in the movement.
Badie is following Aboul Fotouh´s meteoric rise with great concern,
especially the support he has won among young members of the
Brotherhood, as well as young secular people who see him as an option
free of ties to the previous regime. Aboul Fotouh is successfully
marketing a liberal Islamic message. This may be the fact that caused
Badie to consider the possibility of running a movement candidate for
the presidency at the same time as he removed Aboul Fotouh from the
ranks.
The Salafi movement, which registered the most surprising victory in
the elections for parliament, will also offer a candidate: Hazem Abu
Ismail. Perhaps a bit surprisingly, Abu Ismail has taken a positive
approach to Israel and the Jews in his media interviews. He has said
he would refrain from taxing gambling because it is forbidden by the
Islamic religion, and that Israel has already done so out of Jewish
religious considerations.
Abu Ismail is not the only one to mention Israel in a positive light
during the elections. Another candidate, Sabar Hafaz, an Egyptian
businessman, claims he has a plan to solve all of Egypt´s problems.
It is based on building strong ties with, paradoxically, Israel, by
establishing joint economic projects. Hafaz says that Egypt can this
way attract many investors when they realize that war between the
countries is no longer relevant.
More and more names pop up all the time. The hot one these days is
Omar Suleiman, once Mubarak´s head of intelligence. A large rally for
him was to be held today in Cairo. Former Prime Minister Ahmed Shafik
is also thought to be a prominent candidate, as are Hossam
Khairallah, former head of intelligence services, and Hisham Al-
Bastawisi, former deputy chief of the court of appeals.
What leading candidates Moussa and Aboul Fotouh have in common,
according to former Israeli ambassador to Egypt Yitzhak Levanon, is
their near-open hostility toward Israel. "There is no candidate that
may be seen as a potential partner with whom ´to do business,´" he
says. "And there is not one prominent, popular personality who can
sweep voters off their feet. Amr Moussa does not have the support of
either the Muslim Brotherhood or the Salafis. Ahmed Shafik, the
former prime minister, works very hard and is quite capable. But it´s
not clear whether he has a chance."
Levanon warns that if a member of the Muslim Brotherhood runs for the
presidency, its complete control of Egypt is a possibility. "The
election of one of their people to the presidency means a connection
between the legislature and the administrative government," Levanon
says. "All democracies require the separation of powers. It will be
worrying if these two bodies are joined." (© Copyright 2012 Ha´aretz
03/30/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY