Trendy Anti-Zionism Splits Brooklyn (COMMENTARY MAGAZINE) Seth Mandel 03/27/12)
Source: http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2012/03/27/trendy-anti-zionism-splits-brooklyn/
Commentary Magazine
Commentary Magazine Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
“When we talk about hummus,” the Israeli academic Dafna Hirsch tells
New York Magazine’s Matthew Shaer, “we talk on the material level and
also the symbolic level. There is a mythology that completely
surrounds hummus that doesn’t surround a lot of other foods. It’s a
fascinating thing.”
Shaer was writing on the occasion of tonight’s vote-on-a-vote among
the Park Slope faithful: whether the socially-conscious members of a
popular Brooklyn food co-op should take another vote at a later date
on whether to boycott Israeli products. Hirsch was not speaking
specifically about this proposed boycott, but her comment about
symbolism was appropriate: the food co-op isn’t exactly filled to the
brim with products made in Israel. But the number of items isn’t the
point. It’s the symbolic importance of expressing a chic hostility to
the Jewish state. As Ruthie Blum put it in Israel Hayom last week:
The Jews of Park Slope are living very near to where their great-
grandparents settled after getting off the boat at Ellis Island.
However poor and dirty Brooklyn was in those days, it constituted
freedom from an actual evil occupation – that of the Nazis. And
however gentrified much of the New York City borough has become, many
of its Jewish residents still care enough about the quality and price
of their kosher food to join a food cooperative.
With a threat as great as Hitler’s annihilation machine looming large
today, they should be ashamed of themselves for tolerating any
assistance whatsoever to its enablers. In so doing, they are
dishonoring their heritage and endangering their future.
Lest you think Blum is being unfairly unkind to the aimless allies of
the destroy-Israel movement, New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg was
even harsher:
“I think it has nothing to do with the food,” he said of the
boycott. “The issue is there are people who want Israel to be torn
apart and everybody to be massacred, and America is not going to let
that happen.”
The New York Times notes, “The boycott would be largely symbolic,
because the co-op carries only a half-dozen or so products imported
from Israel, including paprika, olive pesto and vegan marshmallows.”
It’s possible if you have not recently been to Brooklyn, that
sentence may strike you as absurd. But that is the modern reality for
the borough’s residents, living among self-styled problem-solvers
apparently in desperate need of real problems to solve–like how to
stop the infiltration of Israeli vegan marshmallows.
As you might expect, Bloomberg is not the only city official who
understands the inanity of the vote:
Christine C. Quinn, the City Council speaker, called the idea “ill
conceived.” Bill de Blasio, the public advocate, said it
was “madness.” Scott M. Stringer, the Manhattan borough president,
described the proposal as “an anti-Semitic crusade.”
Because there are a not-insignificant number of Israeli immigrants
and their descendants in Brooklyn (close to 8,000 as of the 2000
census), and New York is famous for welcoming immigrants, one can
imagine why these politicians aren’t crazy about the Park Slopers’
hostile “activism.”
New Yorkers are generally a quite proud people when it comes to their
city. Let’s hope Bloomberg, Quinn and the others speak for many
Brooklynites in their hopes that this shameful episode passes without
bringing the city any more embarrassment.
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY