Meet Egypt’s Next Prime Minister (FrontPageMagazine.com) by Daniel Greenfield 03/20/12)
Front Page Magazine.com
Front Page Magazine.com Articles-Index-Top
In the fall of 2005, a cheerful editorial appeared in The Guardian
urging its leftist readers not to fear the Muslim Brotherhood.
Identifying himself as the Vice-President of the Muslim Brotherhood,
Khairat El-Shater wrote, “The success of the Muslim Brotherhood
should not frighten anybody: we respect the rights of all religious
and political groups.”
A year later, El-Shater had been arrested and charged with terrorism,
money-laundering and participating in a banned organization. The
arrest of the top Muslim Brotherhood leader was not a simple matter.
Egyptian police blockaded his neighborhood and raided his home
confiscating computers and mobile phones. It was not the first such
arrest for El-Shater. In 1992, Salsabeel, his company, had been
raided exposing Brotherhood documents plotting an overthrow of the
The Brotherhood had gotten too cocky too fast. Its election victories
in Egypt’s parliament had gone to its head and feeling omnipotent its
student movement tried to intimidate other students on campus by
putting on black paramilitary uniforms and masks with Islamic
slogans, similar to those worn by its Hamas adjunct across the border
in Gaza, and conducting a show of force.
The government cracked down and El-Shater went back to prison. But
these days prison is a long way from his mind as he meets everyone
from the Norwegian Foreign Minister to Senator McCain, who tweeted
that he had a “thoughtful conversation” with the Brotherhood leader.
Khairat El-Shater (full name: Mohamed Khairat Saad Abdel Latif el-
Shater) is no longer a top leader in a banned movement. The
Brotherhood has swept parliament and his investments, frozen after a
money-laundering conviction, are his again. The future of Egypt
belongs to the Brotherhood and as the chief financier and deputy
supreme guide of the group; he is on the ground floor to see those
investments pay off.
There is talk of El-Shater becoming Prime Minister, but whether or
not he takes a title, he is in the driver’s seat of the Brotherhood’s
strategy. The Guardian editorial saw El-Shater in his role of selling
the Brotherhood as a moderate reformist organization to the gullible
West. That is still his job. Western governments are uncertain about
the Brotherhood and Khairat El-Shater is there to present them with a
Brotherhood that is as socialist as the left and as capitalist at the
right, dedicated to free enterprise, social justice and religious
freedom, to open elections and political reforms.
But that Brotherhood is only another mirage in the great desert of
Muslim democracy. The Guidance Council runs the Brotherhood and its
parliamentary majority, derived from the ranks of the Brotherhood, is
bound by oath to obey the Council, not the voters. Despite the
illusion of a democratic election, the Brotherhood’s elite will run
The Muslim Brotherhood’ s official goal is an Islamic state, its
roadmap for getting there is to copy the pro-business Islamic
authoritarianism of Turkey’s AKP Party, which cloaked its suppression
of the opposition and overthrow of the military in democracy and free
enterprise language. Copying the AKP’s commercial oligarchy will be a
snap for Khairat El-Shater who oversaw the massive business assets of
When the Egyptian government froze El-Shater’s assets, they amounted
to nearly 87 million dollars. And that’s still a fraction of the
total assets of the Muslim Brotherhood which derive from the tithes
of its membership and are reinvested into everything from factories
to fast food chains. The Brotherhood is no more committed to free
enterprise than Mubarak was. Like him and the Egyptian military, it
wants a seat at the top of the oligarchy.
El-Shater already sits on the board of several banks and he owns a
number of companies and retail chains and his fortune will only
increase as he gains the ability to dictate the economic future of
the entire country. The Brotherhood’s survival was largely due to its
ability to intertwine its religious, political and commercial
interests, raising money as a religious organization, spending it as
a political organization and investing it in business enterprises.
The conflicts of interest are obvious.
El-Shater’s business interests are not incidental to the Brotherhood
program; they are the point of it all. What the Brotherhood did with
its tithes, it will be able to do on a much larger scale when it
controls the Egyptian economy and the sizable foreign investments.
The tensions between it and the military are not over Islam, but over
the military’s own mirror economic interests. When those issues are
resolved, Egypt will be on its way to becoming a fully Islamic
oligarchy on the model of Iran or the intermediate model of Turkey.
Driving out the Copts is vital not only for religious reasons, but
for economic ones. Turkey’s Varlik Vergisi seizure of property from
Christian and Jewish businessmen helped centralize state control of
the economy. Coptic Christians are more successful than their Muslim
counterparts and those likeliest to leave will be those with the most
money, allowing the Brotherhood to gobble up their assets.
Suppressing the economic power of the military and the Copts will
turn the Brotherhood into an unchallenged oligarchy with near supreme
control of the Egyptian economy.
The men who stand to profit the most from the harassment of the Copts
are El-Shater and his cronies who are following the National
Socialist tactic of persecuting a wealthy minority in order to seize
its assets for themselves. While the Muslim Brotherhood makes public
statements about protecting the Copts, its hidden hand touches off
riots and violence, allowing it to act as persecutor and savior.
The Brotherhood may drop hints about moderating its positions, but
its theological commitments make it impossible to do so and it has no
intention of moderating its goals, only its image. That means
disguising its program for women and minorities in cheerful colors,
playing word games and trotting out talking points like its sizable
Sisterhood wing. The endgame however has never changed.
At the end of 2011, El-Shater met with Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh,
as the latter described the terrorist group as the “Jihadi movement”
of the Brotherhood. But the Brotherhood is already a Jihadi movement.
Its motto was, “Allah is our objective; the Prophet is our leader;
the Quran is our law; Jihad is our way; dying in the way of Allah is
our highest hope.”
The only difference is that the Brotherhood has adopted a different
image than its Hamas arm, but the final aim of all Brotherhood
organizations is to establish an absolute monopoly on power in the
name of Islam. No matter how many times Thomas Friedman has
strawberry juice with El-Shater while discussing reforms, he is not a
reformer, and his mission is to move Egypt and the world backward in
time to the Caliphate. (Copyright © 2012 FrontPageMagazine.com
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY