Enough of Noam Schalit (ISRAEL HAYOM OP-ED) David M. Weinberg 03/16/12)
Reuters News Service
Reuters News Service Articles-Index-Top
In an interview with Channel 10 this week, Noam Schalit, the father
of freed soldier Gilad Schalit, said that if he were Palestinian
he “would try to kidnap Israeli soldiers.” “We also kidnapped British
soldiers when we were fighting for our freedom,” Schalit said. And,
for good measure, he added that he was in favor of negotiating with
Hamas.“I am in favor of speaking to anyone who wants to talk to us.”
It’s time to take the gloves off and tell Noam Schalit to clam up.
For a very long time, the Israeli public has treated the elder
Schalit with sympathy and forgiveness, even when he went around the
country blaming the Israeli government, and not Hamas, for his son’s
lengthy captivity, even when he called the prime minister nasty
names, even when he accused Israeli leaders of practically murdering
his son, even when he disrupted formal Independence Day ceremonies
with protests, even when he turned this country’s defense and
security policy on terrorists and captives on its head with a slick
campaign that wasn’t necessarily in our best national interests.
But we all forgave Noam Schalit because he was, well, fighting for
his son, and who could judge him in such a situation? Nobody wanted
to be in his shoes, so we cut him a tremendous amount of slack. The
emotional pressure he placed on us all was overwhelming, and the
Israeli public buckled. Our compassion got the better of us -- for
the sake of Gilad, for Noam, and for the whole Schalit family.
With Gilad back in Mitzpe Hila after a controversial and gut-
wrenching mega-deal with the Hamas in which more than 1,000
terrorists were exchanged for Gilad Schalit, Noam Schalit should have
known well enough to retreat to the privacy of his home and
concentrate on rehabilitating his son and raising his other children.
His manipulations over our emotions and national policies should have
come to an end. He should have realized that his credit with the
public had been used up. The only public expressions to which he
still has a right are expressions of gratitude.
Just a reminder: When, last Friday, the Israel Defense Forces
targeted Zuhair al-Kaisi, secretary-general of the Popular Resistance
Committees in Gaza, we also killed his driver, who happened to be one
of the Hamas prisoners released in the exchange for Gilad Schalit and
who had signed a written pledge not to return to terrorist activity.
(No doubt the two militants were discussing how to make peace with
the Schalits and other nice Israelis as they drove to their afternoon
This sad reality ought to keep Noam Schalit really quiet.
But no. Gratitude and circumspection don’t seem to be Noam Schalit’s
thing. He has unwisely decided to run for Knesset on an opposition
party slate – a slap in the face to Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu, who made the difficult decision to swap terrorists for his
son. Then he took to demeaning Netanyahu, dismissing the prime
minister’s decision to free Gilad as being motivated only by the
“I think the prime minister sees lots of polls,” Schalit told Channel
10. “Every poll found that 70 percent of the public wanted the deal
and it even got to 80 percent. Netanyahu saw the public would not
tolerate a repeat of what happened to [missing airman] Ron Arad.”
Now Noam Schalit outrageously tells us that if he were Palestinian he
too would try to kidnap Israeli soldiers. In saying this, he is
justifying Hamas abductions of soldiers, encouraging Hamas to grab
and torture other Israeli boys and their families, and besmirching
the memory of Menachem Begin (by comparing Etzel actions to those of
But Schalit’s chutzpah runs even deeper. After all, he is partly
responsible for the ugly calculation that it is worthwhile for
Palestinians to abduct Israeli soldiers. The Arabs know there will be
people like Noam Schalit who will agitate for wildly disproportionate
and dangerous prisoner swaps.
The natural reaction to such obtuse and ungrateful statements is to
shrug them off as the nonsensical ramblings of a tortured man who has
been through hell. He’s not completely rational, poor Noam Schalit.
We’ll overlook his insulting imprudence.
But on the chance that Noam Schalit might take our collective silence
as more than mere forbearance, I think it is time to tell him
directly: Enough. Our patience has run out over your insensitive and
tendentious statements. Go back home, and stop embarrassing your son
and yourself, and insulting the rest of us.
The Talmud instructs us not to judge a man’s actions when he is
suffering. It was appropriate to swallow Noam Schalit’s exploitative
behavior while his son was held in captivity. Now that Gilad Schalit
is free and the suffering is over, we need not endure the elder
Schalit’s insults any longer.
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY