U.N. Panel Accuses Syrian Government of Crimes Against Humanity (NY) TIMES) By ALAN COWELL and STEVEN LEE MYERS LONDON, ENGLAND 02/24/12)
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/24/world/middleeast/un-panel-accuses-syria-of-crimes-against-humanity.html
NEW YORK TIMES
NEW YORK TIMES Articles-Index-Top
Publishers-Index-Top
LONDON — A United Nations panel concluded Thursday that “gross human
rights violations” had been ordered by the Syrian authorities as a
matter of state policy, amounting to crimes against humanity.
The panel of three investigators, led by Paulo Pinheiro, a Brazilian
professor, said the orders had come from “the highest levels of armed
forces and the government,” but did not release the names of the
officials it had identified as bearing responsibility. Instead, the
panel delivered the names in a sealed envelope to the United Nations’
top human rights official.
The 72-page report said that the insurgent Free Syrian Army, made up
of defectors from forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad, had also
committed abuses, but that those were “not comparable in scale and
organization to those carried out by the state.”
The report was released on the eve of a major international gathering
in Tunisia to discuss ways to intensify diplomatic and economic
pressure on Syria’s government to halt the violence. Representatives
from dozens of countries are not expected to discuss military options
at the meeting, even for delivering aid, but they will demand a cease-
fire that would allow supplies into areas now under assault. Although
there have been calls to arm the opposition, that is not on the
agenda.
Syrian security forces bombarded areas of Homs, a city in central
Syria, for a 20th successive day on Thursday, despite a growing
outcry.
“No words can describe the damage in the streets,” said an activist
in the Baba Amr neighborhood who used a nom de guerre, Al-Jid. “The
snipers are spread all around. The shelling for the past two days was
the worst.”
At least four people died in the city on Thursday, and activists say
the toll in recent weeks has been in the hundreds; there have been
frequent reports of desperate shortages of medicine and food as the
siege has continued.
The Local Coordination Committees, an opposition group, said that
more than two dozen people had also been killed in the city of Hama,
but did not elaborate on the circumstances of the deaths. Reuters,
citing activists in Hama, said that government security forces had
lined up and fatally shot 13 men and boys from one extended family in
the village of Kfartoun in Hama Province. Neither the death tolls,
nor the report of the massacre, could be independently confirmed.
Activist groups reported dozens of people killed in heavy fighting in
Idlib Province as well.
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and several foreign
ministers of European and Arab countries met in London on Thursday
ahead of the international “Friends of Syria” meeting in Tunis. They
discussed urgent efforts to provide humanitarian assistance,
especially medical supplies to Homs and other battered cities. A
senior State Department official traveling with Mrs. Clinton said
that countries were ready to provide considerable assistance “within
days” through United Nations relief agencies, but that “the real
challenge is the access issue.”
In a press conference Thursday, Mrs. Clinton moved the United States
a step closer to recognizing the Syrian National Council, an exile
opposition group, though a formal recognition is not expected in
Tunis. She also said later, discussing growing pressure on Mr.
Assad: “There will be increasingly capable opposition forces. They
will — from somewhere, somehow — find the means to defend themselves
as well as begin offensive measures. And the pressure will build on
countries like Russia and China because world opinion is not going to
stand idly by.”
Both countries recently vetoed a United Nations Security Council
resolution supporting a plan to end the bloodshed. Russia has said it
will not attend the Tunisia meeting and news reports on Thursday said
China had not committed, blunting the gathering’s chances of securing
strong action against Mr. Assad’s government.
On Thursday, the former United Nations secretary general, Kofi Annan,
was appointed as the joint United Nations-Arab League envoy on the
Syrian crisis.
The United Nations report released Thursday argued that Syria was
now “on the brink” of civil war and said “the continuation of the
crisis carries the risk of radicalizing the population, deepening
inter-communal tensions and eroding the fabric of society.”
“The commission received credible and consistent evidence,” the
investigators said, “identifying high- and mid-ranking members of the
armed forces who ordered their subordinates to shoot at unarmed
protesters, kill soldiers who refused to obey such orders, arrest
persons without cause, mistreat detained persons and attack civilian
neighborhoods with indiscriminate tanks and machine-gun fire.”
The investigators said the report was based on 369 interviews with
victims, witnesses, defectors, other people with “inside knowledge”
of the situation in Syria and some government supporters. They also
examined photographs, video recordings and satellite imagery to
corroborate some witness accounts of the unrelenting crackdown on
those who have been protesting Mr. Assad’s leadership for months.
The investigators said they had not been allowed to enter Syria to
conduct inquiries, but did many interviews by phone and spoke in
person with people who had fled the country.
There was no immediate response by the Syrian authorities.
Accusations of human rights abuses made last November were rejected
as false by the Syrian diplomatic mission in Geneva in a statement on
Jan. 23 that said “armed terrorist groups,” not government forces,
were responsible.
Among the scores of people who activist groups reported were killed
by rockets and bombs through the day on Wednesday in Homs were
Western journalists, the veteran American war correspondent Marie
Colvin, who had been working for The Sunday Times of London, and a
young French photographer, Rémi Ochlik. The two had been working in a
makeshift media center that was destroyed in the assault. Activists
said that the center had been targeted and that Syrian reconnaissance
aircraft had probably spotted satellite transmitters on the roof of
the building where it was located. The government denied targeting
journalists.
The killings provoked outrage, with powerful media figures and
European politicians calling on Syrian forces to permit the retrieval
of the bodies. At least two other journalists were wounded on
Wednesday, and their newspapers in London and Paris said they were
trying to find ways to rescue them.
One of the wounded journalists, Edith Bouvier, 31, is a freelancer
for the newspaper Le Figaro. Videos on YouTube showed her and Paul
Conroy, a photographer who lives in Britain, appealing for help.
One of the videos also shows a Syrian man in medical scrubs and a
stethoscope who seconded Ms. Bouvier’s call for immediate evacuation
and said her life was in danger. “We need help to stop the
bombardments and save Edith,” the man said in Arabic.
According to Syria’s official SANA news agency, the Foreign Ministry
in Damascus on Thursday rejected “all statements that hold Syria
accountable for the death of journalists who infiltrated Syria at
their own risk without the Syrian authorities’ knowledge of their
entry and whereabouts.”
Activists, civilian journalists and foreign correspondents who have
sneaked into Syria have infuriated the authorities and foiled the
government’s efforts to control the coverage of clashes.
President Nicolas Sarkozy of France called the journalists’
killings “murder,” and France’s foreign minister, Alain Juppé, said
France had asked Syria to organize the rapid evacuation of Ms.
Bouvier and other foreign reporters. “I vigorously protest the
situation of journalists in Homs,” Mr. Juppé said, according to
Agence France-Presse. “What’s happening in Syria is more revolting,
more shameful and scandalous every day.”
Reporting was contributed by Rod Nordland from Cairo; Hwaida Saad and
Neil MacFarquhar from Beirut, Lebanon; John F. Burns from London;
Steven Erlanger, Maïa de la Baume and Scott Sayare from Paris; and
Ellen Barry from Moscow. (Copyright 2012 The New York Times Company
02/24/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY