Defense Ministry, IDF drafting replacement for invalidated Tal Law (HAŽARETZ NEWS) By Amos Harel and Gili Cohen 02/23/12)
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE
HA'ARETZ} NEWS SERVICE Articles-Index-Top
The Defense Ministry is drafting a bill to enable more ultra-Orthodox
men to be conscripted, now that the High Court of Justice has
invalidated the law governing draft exemptions for yeshiva students.
Defense Minister Ehud Barak has given detailed guidelines on what the
bill should include to ministry legal adviser Ahaz Benari. He drafted
the guidelines after meeting with senior Israel Defense Forces
officers, including Chief of Staff Benny Gantz, to get their input on
Barak´s proposal calls for service for all, but on different tracks.
The IDF would be given first crack at the draft pool, so it can
conscript the soldiers it needs. Those not chosen by the IDF would do
a year of national service in the police, the fire service, or the
Magen David Adom ambulance service, or else a year of civilian
service in their communities, but under much stricter supervision
than has been the case until now.
Under the plan, those who do IDF service would receive compensation:
a monthly salary close to the minimum wage starting in their second
year of service. This salary would be saved for them until they are
discharged, when they could use it for their education.
Barak and senior IDF officers also suggested making a distinction
between combat and noncombat soldiers, with combat soldiers getting a
Finally, Barak proposed that a limited number of outstanding yeshiva
students be allowed to remain in yeshiva full-time rather than doing
either civilian or military service. But this group would be limited
to 2,000 to 3,000 men at any given time, rather than the over 8,000
who currently receive draft exemptions every year.
During the next several weeks, the IDF will set up working groups to
discuss developing mechanisms for drafting Haredi (ultra-Orthodox)
A massive draft of Haredim would have significant financial
ramifications. According to a Personnel Directorate officer, a
soldier in the Shahar project, which integrates Haredim into
technical jobs in the army, costs the IDF five times as much as a
regular soldier. This is because Haredim tend to marry young, and
payments to the wife of a married conscript can reach NIS 4,000 a
Married soldiers also get another few hundred shekels to help them
pay their rent or mortgage.
Moreover, large numbers of Haredi soldiers will force a
reorganization of IDF training programs. A significant number of
combat instructors are women, but the army sends only male
instructors to the one Haredi battalion (Nahal Haredi) and to
platoons with large numbers of yeshiva students, as well as to Druze
and Bedouin battalions.
At the army´s recruitment offices in Tel Hashomer yesterday, business
was pretty much as usual: Teenagers were awaiting their initial army
placement tests, and Haredi men were waiting to extend their draft
deferments. Even with the High Court decision, the Taw Law, which
governs these deferments, remains in effect until August.
Most of those waiting didn´t believe that all those currently exempt
would be drafted.
"I simply don´t believe it will happen, unless the rabbis decide
that´s what should be done," said a 26-year-old Haredi man from Bnei
Brak, who preferred not to give his name. "If we´re drafted, we´ll
all go in together. The most important thing is that we be allowed to
keep the commandments. If that happens, then we´ll obey." (©
Copyright 2012 Ha´aretz 02/23/12)
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY