Leftists Caught Red-Handed: ‘Burning Sheep’ Libel Was Faked (INN) ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS) by Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu 12/26/10)
INN} ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS
INN} ISRAEL NATIONAL NEWS Articles-Index-Top
A Jordan Valley Arab farmer has exposed the tactic of leftists
accepting Arab claims and falsely accusing Jews of attacking Arabs.
He admitted that the “burning sheep” libel against Jews was meant to
disguise his own blunder of losing control of a brush fire.
Last week, left-wing groups in Israel and counterparts in the United
States spread a story that that an Arab shepherd “saw settlers light
a fire in the field where his herd was grazing, burning to death 12
pregnant ewes, and then drive away."
The story of the sheep burning was so extreme that the police
immediately doubted the claim. The supposed burning of the sheep
occurred on the Sabbath, when observant Jews, the usual scapegoats,
are forbidden to drive.
The Arab farmer, Samir Bani Fadel, claimed that four armed Jews
approached him, chased him away, set fire to his field – which also
is forbidden on Sabbath – and drove away as the fire spread and
burned to death 12 pregnant ewes while injuring others.
Regardless of the doubts, the left-wing B´Tselem and Yesh Din human
rights group rushed to allege that the supposed attack was another
one of hundreds of supposed acts of vandalism by Jews against Arabs.
New York-based writer Philip Weiss promptly reprinted the libel on
his Mondoweiss blog, and the image of sheep being cruelly burned
aroused sympathy for Arabs and anger against Jews. “It was an awful
sight,” the farmer said. "I´ve lost at least $12,000."
The Palestinian Authority called on the international community to
pressure Israel to stop "settler violence.”
The tale began to unravel when Arabs pointed their fingers at
residents of Itamar, an easy target as it is a religious community,
but located almost an hour’s drive from the scene of the fire. The
story then was changed, with the blame being placed on the closer
community of Maaleh Ephraim, most of whose residents are
professionals and who almost never have been accused of any
activities against Arabs.
Fadel finally admitted to police the whole story was a lie and that
he was responsible for the fire, which he set to burn thorns before
it spread beyond control. Blaming Jews not only would have saved him
from the embarrassment of having burned his own sheep, it also would
allow him to claim damages from the government while being hailed as
a hero among Palestinian Authority Arabs and left-wing anti-Zionists.
Hundreds of accusations against Jewish residents of Judea and Samaria
have been leveled in recent years, usually in claims that Jews attack
or destroy olive trees, although evidence has been produced that in
most cases the Arabs have simply pruned their trees, counted on lack
of agricultural knowledge on the part of the media and leftwing
groups, and then accused Jews of damaging them. Olive trees look
hacked when they are pruned and months later, the supposedly damaged
orchards have been seen to be full of fruit.
Another tactic has been to instigate violence, especially on the
Shabbat when Jews are forbidden to take pictures, and then accuse
Jews of attacking them.
Yossi Dagan, adviser to the Samaria Regional Council,
commented, “There is a system among left-wing groups who campaign for
financial contributions from foreign countries, many of whom are
hostile to Israel. They use European Union money, which has reached
billions of dollars the past few years. Many of the workers for left-
wing groups enjoy high salaries and use reports from so-called human
rights organizations and then travel throughout Judea and Samaria and
blow up or change facts to spread libel against Jews.”
Dagan explained that Jews are blamed for burning cars in Arab
villages when in fact they are damaged as a result of fights among
David Ha’Ivri, who heads the Shomron (Samaria) Liaison Office that
handles public relations for the Jewish communities in Samaria,
said, "We have a very difficult task up against a bunch of well-
funded NGOs like B’Tselem and Rabbis for Human Rights, whose agenda
is to hurt the image of the State of Israel and the Jewish residents
of Yehuda and Shomron (Judea and Samaria).
“Their slanderous claims are always given the benefit of the doubt by
international media agencies who jump at an opportunity to project a
Satanic image of the ‘evil Jewish settlers.’ The events reported in
this story are a perfect example of blood libel promoted by NGOs who
claim to be humanitarian and peace activists.” (© IsraelNN
Return to Top
MATERIAL REPRODUCED FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY